After the Parkland massacre, more states consider ‘red flag’ gun bills

Mar 7, 2018, 11:43 PM | Updated: Jun 7, 2022, 3:59 pm

(CNN) — Even before the Parkland school shooting raised questions about warning signs exhibited by gunman Nikolas Cruz, at least 19 state legislatures were already considering “red flag” bills that would let a court temporarily prohibit someone from possessing or buying firearms if they’re deemed to pose a threat to themselves or others.

Now even more states are considering such laws after the February 14 massacre at Florida’s Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, which galvanized discussion about them even at a national level and prompted House Democrats propose grants for states that enact them.

Supporters say such measures would fill a gap in current law. Critics say they infringe on due process by letting a judge make an initial decision — even if temporary — without hearing from the accused, and by allowing the judge to curtail someone’s Second Amendment right to bear arms without the respondent ever having been convicted of a crime or been adjudged mentally ill.

Here’s a closer look:

Where are they allowed now, and what do they do?

Such laws — variously known as extreme risk protection orders (ERPOs), gun violence restraining orders and red-flag laws — are in effect in Connecticut (enacted in 1999), Indiana (2005), California (2014), Washington (2016), and Oregon (2017).

The laws differ state to state, but they generally allow specific people — law enforcement officers and, in some states, relatives of the person in question — to ask a judge to temporarily prohibit someone from having or buying firearms.

This would be based not primarily on criminal history or mental health disqualifications already enshrined in law, but rather over allegations that the person is likely to harm themselves or others.

The judge, after considering evidence, can:

1) Make an initial ruling immediately preventing the person from purchasing guns and requiring them to surrender any they have. This initial order can take place without the respondent in the court.

2) Within a few days or weeks, hold a second hearing, which the respondent would attend. If the judge determines there’s convincing evidence that the respondent poses a significant danger to himself or herself or others, the order would be extended, generally up to a year.

The longer order would expire at the end of the specified term, unless someone petitions to renew it.

Specific instructions on factors the judge is to weigh vary from law to law. But generally, the laws tell judges to look for a recent act of violence or threats of violence — such as posts on social media — against the person in question or others.

Other factors are also weighed. Florida’s proposed law, for instance, would instruct judges to consider evidence of mental health issues, stalking and alcohol or drug abuse.

Where else are they proposed?

Even before the Parkland shooting, bills establishing EPROs were in front of at least 19 state legislatures — either under active consideration or at least introduced — this year.

Those states are: Alaska, Arizona, Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, North Carolina, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee, Virginia and Vermont.

Since Parkland, bills were introduced in at least five more states: Alabama, Kentucky, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Utah.

At least 31 states either are considering bills or have lawmakers who have committed to introducing them, according to the American State Legislators for Gun Violence Prevention, which describes itself as a nonpartisan coalition of 200 lawmakers across the country who want to stop firearms crimes.

How do these compare to other laws?

Under federal law, gun possession is generally prohibited for convicted felons, or people who are convicted of domestic violence or are subject to certain restraining orders. Federal law also can prevent people from purchasing or possessing a firearm due to a mental illness under two conditions: if he or she is involuntarily committed to a mental hospital, or if a court or government body declares him or her mentally incompetent.

Laws in some states mirror the federal prohibitions and in many cases expand them, including for those with drug and alcohol abuse histories and violent misdemeanor offenses.

ERPOs, supporters say, are meant to fill what they see as a gap. Other laws prohibit gun ownership for previously adjudicated crimes or mental health dispositions, but ERPOs, they say, are meant to allow action to be taken before a crime or suicide is attempted, when evidence shows danger is imminent.

‘(We) don’t have to wait for something terrible to happen’

New York state Sen. Brian Kavanagh, chairman of the lawmakers’ gun violence coalition, said people “don’t have to wait for something terrible to happen” before addressing whether someone who’s been shown to be a threat should have guns.

“We’re saying: There’s many circumstances where crimes have not been committed, or a person not been brought (to authorities’ attention, or no diagnosis has been made), but there’s a lot of evidence that they may be a danger to themselves or others,” Kavanagh said.

“This fills what we think is the fundamental gap in gun violence prevention in America, which is there is no mechanism to address a situation where someone may be dangerous to themselves or others, but has not committed a crime or had experience with a mental health system which would cause them to be prohibited,” the senator said.

Another ERPO supporter is Nicole Hockley, a managing director of Sandy Hook Promise, a nonprofit that works to change public policy and prevent gun violence. Her 6-year-old son was among the 20 kindergartners and first-graders and six adults killed in the 2012 Sandy Hook elementary school shooting in Connecticut.

Hockley says ERPOs are just one move among many that can help combat gun violence. But this, she said, is something that works and “should be embraced.”

Background checks, she says, generally take a historical perspective.

“This (ERPO) is saying, forget about history. What’s going on right now?” she said.

Studies on the effectiveness of current extreme risk protection order laws are few. But supporters point to a Duke University study of 762 gun removals under Connecticut’s ERPO law from 1999 to 2013. The study estimated that one suicide may have been prevented for every 10 to 20 gun seizures.

Who is against them, and why?

The laws have drawn criticism from a range of observers, including gun-rights proponents and a state chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union.

The Gun Owners of America firearms lobbying group points especially to the initial petition hearing, for which the respondent isn’t present. The group warns of false accusations.

“No one should lose any of their rights without due process. Otherwise, people can make a false claim to get revenge or to disarm the person they’re stalking,” the group said in an emailed statement.

“States that have enacted gun confiscation orders are disarming people without a jury trial or without their attorneys present. In fact, the first time the person finds out about the gun confiscation order is typically when police are knocking on the door to take their firearms.”

“This is very dangerous for all our rights, as it moves us to a ‘Minority Report’ type of society, where one can lose their rights for what they ‘might do’ in the future.”

Dudley Brown, president of the National Association for Gun Rights, also was concerned about due process.

“It’s essentially (just) saying, ‘I don’t think somebody should have a gun.'”

He also said he believes ERPOs would be ineffective, because a prohibited respondent can still obtain guns by stealing them.

The ACLU of Rhode Island said that Rhode Island’s proposed law, which is similar to the others, is well-intentioned but overly broad.

“While the ACLU of Rhode Island recognizes the bill’s laudable goal, we are deeply concerned about its breadth, its impact on civil liberties, and the precedent it sets for the use of coercive measures against individuals not because they are alleged to have committed any crime, but because somebody believes they might, someday, commit one,” the group said.

‘Thorny issue’

CNN legal analyst Page Pate says the judge’s initial, ex parte order indeed infringes on due process, but the question is whether it’s reasonable, given the circumstances and the promise of a full hearing. Temporary, ex parte orders already are issued for domestic violence cases, for instance.

“Ultimately I think courts will decide, yes, it is an infringement (of due process), but a reasonable one,” the Atlanta-based criminal defense and constitutional lawyer said.

A trickier question, he said, is whether ERPOs — because they deprive someone of every type of firearm in every circumstance without a conviction or determination of mental illness — can survive Second Amendment challenges.

“It’s a thorny issue” that may be challenged in court as more states enact these laws, Pate said.

™ & © 2018 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

KSL 5 TV Live

Top Stories


A woman is pushing a patient bed through a hospital hallway....
Deidre McPhillips, CNN

Hospitals in the US are the fullest they’ve been throughout the pandemic — but it’s not just COVID-19

(CNN) — Hospitals are more full than they’ve been throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a CNN analysis of data from the US Department of Health and Human Services. But as respiratory virus season surges across the US, it’s much more than Covid that’s filling beds this year. More than 80% of hospital beds are […]
1 day ago
Two women are signing banknotes....
Betsy Klein, CNN

Yellen sees her signature printed on US bills for the first time

US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen traveled to Texas Thursday to mark an important and historic milestone, touring the Fort Worth Bureau of Engraving and Printing facility to observe firsthand the printing of $1 and $5 bills with her signature for the first time.
1 day ago
Mortgage rates fall for the fourth week in a row. Pictured is a housing development in Folsom, Cali...
Anna Bahney, CNN

Mortgage rates fall for the fourth week in a row

Mortgage rates dipped again this week, dropping for the fourth week in a row.
1 day ago
Investigators seek information on a white sedan seen near where four Idaho college students were ki...
Aya Elamroussi, CNN

New details emerge about a vehicle at the scene of the grisly Idaho student stabbings

Investigators in the killings of four University of Idaho students are searching for at least one person they believe was inside a white sedan seen near the crime scene.
1 day ago
Singer Lana Del Rey, seen here arriving at the Variety 2021 Music Hitmakers Brunch held at the City...
Sandra Gonzalez, CNN

Lana Del Rey announces new album to debut next year

If your day needs a Rey of sunshine, here's some good news for you: Lana Del Rey has announced a new album.
2 days ago
Cold Moon Rises In Italy, L'aquila - 19 Dec 2021....
Taylor Nicioli, CNN

Full ‘cold moon’ shines bright and eclipses Mars in a rare event

December's full moon, also known as the "cold moon," will shine bright in the night sky this Wednesday, peaking at 9:08 p.m. MT.
2 days ago

Sponsored Articles

notebook with password notes highlighted...
PC Laptops

How to Create Strong Passwords You Can Actually Remember

Learn how you can create strong passwords that are actually easy to remember! In a short time you can create new ones in seconds.
house with for rent sign posted...
Chase Harrington, president and COO of Entrata

Top 5 reasons you may want to consider apartment life over owning a home

There are many benefits of renting that can be overshadowed by the allure of buying a home. Here are five reasons why renting might be right for you.
Festive kitchen in Christmas decorations. Christmas dining room....
Lighting Design

6 Holiday Decor Trends to Try in 2022

We've rounded out the top 6 holiday decor trends for 2022 so you can be ahead of the game before you start shopping. 
Happy diverse college or university students are having fun on their graduation day...
BYU MBA at the Marriott School of Business

How to choose what MBA program is right for you: Take this quiz before you apply!

Wondering what MBA program is right for you? Take this quiz before you apply to see if it will help you meet your goals.
Diverse Group of Energetic Professionals Team Meeting in Modern Office: Brainstorming IT Programmer...
Les Olson

Don’t let a ransomware attack get you down | Protect your workplace today with cyber insurance

Business owners and operators should be on guard to protect their workplace. Cyber insurance can protect you from online attacks.
Hand turning a thermostat knob to increase savings by decreasing energy consumption. Composite imag...
Lighting Design

5 Lighting Tips to Save Energy and Money in Your Home

Advances in lighting technology make it easier to use smart features to cut costs. Read for tips to save energy by using different lighting strategies in your home.
After the Parkland massacre, more states consider ‘red flag’ gun bills