Attorneys Say Criminal Case Against Girl’s Uncle Strong, Even Before Body Recovered

May 29, 2019, 6:31 PM

CACHE COUNTY, Utah — This morning, the Cache County Attorney filed aggravated murder charges against 21-year-old Alex Whipple in the death of five-year-old Elizabeth Shelley.

That charge carries the potential for the death penalty, though that has now been taken off the table in exchange for information from Whipple that led police to Elizabeth’s remains.

But, could a murder case have been made without first finding Elizabeth?

According to the charging documents, Cache County prosecutors believed they had enough evidence to show Whipple murdered “Lizzy” Shelley even before finding her body. A couple of criminal defense attorneys who also worked previously as prosecutors shared their thoughts.

“It looks to be a pretty compelling case, or at least a case where the prosecution has what we call probable cause to charge him,” said Greg Skordas a criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor in Salt Lake County who is not working on this case.

After reading the probable cause statement, he thinks Cache County prosecutors had a good case against Alex Whipple even before they located the body.

“It’s difficult for a prosecutor to charge a homicide without a body. But it’s not impossible,” said Skordas. “What they need is substantial evidence.”

Like this evidence spelled out in the probable cause statement:

“There is evidence including Elizabeth’s blood found on a knife, Elizabeth’s blood found on Alexander, and Alexander’s partial right palm print found in the red substance on the PVC pipe to believe Alexander has committed the aggravated murder of Elizabeth Shelley.”

“It looks like the law enforcement has done a pretty thorough investigation,” said Skordas. “They have DNA, and they’ve actually processed the DNA.”

“It is better to have a body, and the legal concept we’re talking about is ‘corpus delicti’, which means ‘body of the crime,'” said former prosecutor, B. Kent Morgan.

He said all crimes demand proof of what happened. Prosecutors may have been able to prove the murder case to a jury without the body or human remains, said Morgan. But, a defense attorney could have argued there was still reasonable doubt about her death.

“As a defense attorney, you don’t have to prove that it’s true, you have to prove that there’s reasonable doubt,” he said.

Now, there appears to be evidence that Elizabeth was kidnapped from her home and killed.  All of the other evidence collected before they found her remains now provides a clearer picture as the investigation continues.

KSL 5 TV Live

Top Stories

Local News

A destroyed home in Ukraine...
Kiersten Nunez

Local nonprofit aims to fix lost homes in Ukraine

The nonprofit August Mission hopes to raise enough money to rehouse Ukrainians who lost their homes during the conflict against Russia.
1 day ago
A barbeque caught on fire at house in Sandy....
Michael Houck

Barbeque fire catches Sandy house on fire; displaces family

A barbeque caught on fire, causing a 2nd alarm house fire in Sandy Sunday evening.
1 day ago
FILE PHOTO (Idaho State Police/Facebook)...
Michael Houck

Kearns woman killed in two vehicle crash in Idaho

A Kearns woman has died after being hit by a car while on a motorcycle in Idaho Saturday.
1 day ago
Iron County Search & Rescue responded to a injured mountain biker at Boulder Dash Trail. (Credit: I...
Michael Houck

Search & Rescue crews help an injured biker near Cedar City

Iron County Search & Rescue helped a mountain biker who needed help after getting hurt on a trail Saturday morning near Cedar City.
1 day ago
A minor apartment fire on 761 So. 300 E....
Michael Houck

SLC Fire crews take down a minor apartment fire

Salt Lake City Fire crews responded to a minor apartment fire Sunday afternoon.
1 day ago
Utah's state Route 24 on June 23, 2022. (NPS)...
Larry D. Curtis

Flood watch over popular Utah recreation areas Sunday

A flood watch is in effect over central southern Utah, through Sunday night, as thunderstorms create potentially dangerous conditions.
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

hand holding 3d rendering mobile connect with security camera for security solutions...
Les Olson

Wondering what security solutions are right for you? Find out more about how to protect your surroundings

Physical security helps everyone. Keep your employees, clients, and customers safe with security solutions that protect your workplace.
Many rattan pendant lights, hay hang from the ceiling.Traditional and simple lighting....
Lighting Design

The Best Ways to Style Rattan Pendant Lighting in Your Home

Rattan pendant lights create a rustic and breezy feel, and are an easy way to incorporate this hot trend into your home decor.
Earth day 2022...

How Are You Celebrating Earth Day 2022? | 4 Simple Ways to Celebrate Earth Day and Protect the Environment

Earth Day is a great time to reflect on how we can be more environmentally conscious. Here are some tips for celebrating Earth Day.
Get Money Online...

More Ways to Get Money Online Right Now in Your Spare Time

Here are 4 easy ways that you can get more money online if you have some free time and want to make a little extra on the side.
Lighting trends 2022...

Lighting Trends 2022 | 5 Beautiful Home Lighting Trends You Can Expect to See this Year and Beyond

This is where you can see the latest lighting trends for 2022 straight from the Lightovation Show at the Dallas World Trade Center.
What Can't You Throw Away in the Trash...

What Can’t You Throw Away in the Trash? | 5 Things You Shouldn’t Throw in to Your Trash Can

What can't you throw away in the trash? Believe it or not, there are actually many items that shouldn't be thrown straight into the trash.
Attorneys Say Criminal Case Against Girl’s Uncle Strong, Even Before Body Recovered