CORONAVIRUS

House Democrats Investigating Unproven COVID-19 Antibody Tests

Apr 24, 2020, 4:53 PM | Updated: Jul 29, 2022, 11:14 pm
A COVID-19 blood test is administered outside of Delmont Medical Care on April 22, 2020 in Franklin...
A COVID-19 blood test is administered outside of Delmont Medical Care on April 22, 2020 in Franklin Square, New York. The test identifies antibodies to the coronavirus. The World Health Organization declared coronavirus (COVID-19) a global pandemic on March 11th. (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)
(Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)

(CNN) — House Democrats are citing flaws in federal policy that have led to unproven and fraudulently marketed coronavirus antibody tests being sold in the United States, according to a memo shared exclusively with CNN.

The memo, by the House Oversight Subcommittee on Economic and Consumer Policy, says that after a briefing last week by federal officials the subcommittee has found the Food and Drug Administration is “unable to validate the accuracy of antibody tests that are already on the market.” The committee chairman is suggesting the FDA shut the marketplace down until better procedures are in place.

The FDA has granted emergency use authorization to just four antibody tests, and there are dozens more awaiting the same authorization. The FDA has also opened a separate process for more than 100 other non-FDA approved tests to be checked for accuracy. As of Wednesday, only 10 tests had completed testing through that voluntary process, according to one federal agency participating. The agency does not know how many total antibody tests have been shipped to health care providers or how reliable those tests are, according to the memo.

The memo states that the FDA told the subcommittee that it had not yet taken any enforcement action against companies with ineffective or mismarketed tests, and that there is no dedicated enforcement staff.

The FDA told CNN, however, that it is carrying out enforcement measures, pointing to a statement by FDA Commissioner Stephen Hahn the day after the briefing.

“We have and will continue to take appropriate action against firms making or distributing unvalidated tests or those making false claims, such as issuing Warning Letters requesting that companies stop their unlawful promotion and detaining and refusing fraudulent test kits at the border,” Hahn said.

Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi, chair of the subcommittee, said the FDA’s guidelines have created a “wild west” that will put American consumers at risk.

“What I fear is that they’re going to make dangerous life decisions based on those fraudulent testing results,” said Krishnamoorthi, an Illinois Democrat.

Regarding the verification process, an FDA spokesperson said, “FDA will continue to consider the risks and benefits of our policies as the emergency evolves and adjust as necessary.” The person added: “FDA is constantly evaluating whether our policy needs to change based on new information to protect the public health.”

High hopes and challenges for antibody testing

Antibody tests, or serological tests, as they’re also known, could play an important role in plans to reopen the economy. Last week, President Donald Trump said such tests will “support our efforts to get Americans back to work by showing us who might have developed the wonderful, beautiful immunity.”

But many antibody tests are being developed without FDA approval after the agency relaxed its vetting policy on March 16, saying the move “provided regulatory flexibility […] in an effort to provide laboratories and health care providers with early access to these tests.” The FDA had previously been criticized for being too slow to approve independently developed coronavirus tests, even as the CDC’s own early test for the virus proved unreliable.

The problem with antibody tests goes beyond their accuracy: Scientists and health professionals cannot say conclusively whether the presence of antibodies means that someone is immune to COVID-19. They also do not know how long that presumed immunity would last.

“There’s an assumption — a reasonable assumption — that when you have an antibody that you are protected against reinfection, but that has not been proven for this particular virus,” Dr. Anthony Fauci said earlier this week on “Good Morning America.”

Early research has also suggested that not everyone who tests positive for coronavirus will later show a detectable level of antibodies in their blood. “Negative results don’t rule out SARS-CoV-2 infection,” a senior FDA official said in an interview.

But assuming that antibodies do confer some immunity, it’s vital that the tests for them are accurate. Antibody tests can be developed and distributed to the U.S. market in two ways. The first, a more conventional and stringent route, grants companies emergency use authorization after validation of their tests by the FDA. Only four companies thus far have been approved through this process, though dozens of others have applied.

A second route allows manufacturers to develop and distribute their tests without prior FDA approval. Companies who take this course are asked to self-validate their antibody tests and notify the FDA that they have done so. The only other requirement is to clearly label the product with disclaimers, including noting the test has not been reviewed by the FDA, that neither negative or positive results can be conclusively linked to COVID-19 infection, and that test results should not be used as the only basis for diagnosis. This, too, is being handled on the honor system; the FDA is not requesting testing or marketing materials from manufacturers.

After releasing the tests, the companies have the option to voluntarily have their tests verified through a collaboration that includes the FDA, the CDC, the Department of Health and Human Services, and the National Cancer Institute.

A senior FDA official explained that this second route is an attempt to “strike a delicate balance” between “innovation and making sure that consumers have expedient access to test on the market without delay.”

Two studies, out of Stanford and Massachusetts General Hospital, used unapproved antibody tests for research on the community spread of Covid-19, both of which led to valuable insights into the pandemic, the official pointed out.

The CDC did not respond to request for comment by publication time. HHS referred reporters to the FDA. A spokesperson for the National Cancer Institute said that it is “providing performance data of serology testing kits to the FDA” and that it had completed tests for 10 manufacturers and requested kits from another 100, but said that it would defer to the FDA on the results of that verification process.

In his comments on April 18, Hahn acknowledged that some companies have flouted the guidelines, saying that “some test developers have misused the serology test kit notification list to falsely claim their serological tests are FDA approved or authorized.”

A recommendation to “clear the market”

Still, members of Congress believe some tests continue to be offered to consumers with promises that may overreach. “Right now there’s no authorization required, no validation required, no enforcement by the FDA. And as a consequence, you have a situation where con artists are basically able to succeed,” Krishamoorthi said.

Based on the briefing by the FDA, CDC, and HHS, Krishnamoorthi’s subcommittee made a list of preliminary findings. They included findings that “companies are ignoring requests from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to voluntarily submit their tests for validation,” and that “FDA has failed to police the coronavirus serological antibody test market, has taken no public enforcement action against any company, and has not conveyed any clear policy on serological tests, but rather has issued a series of unclear ‘clarifications.'”

As part of their investigation, the subcommittee sent out document requests to at least six companies in the past month that appear to be fraudulently marketing COVID-19 tests. On Thursday they sent another such request to ARCpoint Labs, a South Carolina company operating in 30 states and currently offering antibody testing. The letter to the company claims it appears to be violating FDA policy by offering testing outside of certified labs, as well as overstating the significance of antibody test results and claiming that a positive result for antibodies suggests “‘functional immunity’ and encourages people to ‘[d]iscontinue social distancing.'”

“We received Rep. Krishnamoorthi’s letter, and we are working diligently to address all of the House Oversight subcommittee’s concerns and ensure we are in compliance with current FDA guidelines,” ARCpoint Labs CEO John Constantine said in a statement to CNN.

Krishnamoorthi said that he believes the FDA should “clear the market” and start over. “They should enforce their prerogative to prevent the further sale of these tests,” he said.

Krishnamoorthi emphasized that antibody testing has “great promise.” But, he added, “We don’t want to get into this situation where people get sick again because they relied on wrong testing.” He said the committee would pressure the administration to make what he called “common sense changes” and continue to seek out companies with ineffective or mismarketed tests.

Above all, the White House needs to be realistic about what we do and don’t know about antibody testing at this point, he said. “You can’t reopen the economy based on serological testing,” he said, “unless you incorporate the science and understand its limitations.”

KSL 5 TV Live

Top Stories

Coronavirus

RSV and flu...
Deidre McPhillips, CNN

Flu season intensifies, holiday gatherings could make it worse

Americans gathered for Thanksgiving last week amid a flu season that's worse than any has been in more than a decade, and experts continue to urge caution as multiple respiratory viruses circulate at high levels nationwide.
2 days ago
Protesters hold up blank papers and chant slogans as they march in protest in Beijing, Sunday, Nov....
Jessie Yeung and CNN's Beijing bureau

Rare protests are spreading across China. Here’s what you need to know

From Shanghai to Beijing, protests have erupted across China in a rare show of dissent against the ruling Communist Party.
2 days ago
Police officers block Shanghai's Urumqi Road on Sunday. (Hector Retamal/AFP/Getty Images)...
CNN's Beijing bureau and Nectar Gan

Protests erupt across China in unprecedented challenge to Xi Jinping’s zero-Covid policy

Protests erupted across China throughout the weekend, including at universities and in Shanghai where hundreds chanted "Step down, Xi Jinping! Step down, Communist Party!"
3 days ago
Salt Lake City Police at the University of Utah Hospital due to a possible bomb threat. (Salt Lake ...
Michael Houck

Police: Unattended bag led to bomb squad response at U of U Hospital

Salt Lake City Police responded to a possible bomb threat at the University of Utah hospital Tuesday afternoon.
15 days ago
Evusheld...
Elizabeth Cohen and Naomi Thomas, CNN

COVID-19 medicine for immunocompromised patients is losing effectiveness

Judy Salins considers herself a smart, empowered patient, but until this week, she had no idea that the medicine she takes to defend herself against Covid-19 isn't protecting her as well as it used to.
19 days ago
Paxlovid, the antiviral pill that reduces the risk of hospitalization and death from Covid-19, also...
Jamie Gumbrecht, CNN

Paxlovid reduces risk of long Covid, Veterans Affairs study finds

Paxlovid, the antiviral pill that reduces the risk of hospitalization and death from Covid-19, also reduces the risk of long Covid, according to a new study by the US Department of Veterans Affairs.
24 days ago

Sponsored Articles

house with for rent sign posted...
Chase Harrington, president and COO of Entrata

Top 5 reasons you may want to consider apartment life over owning a home

There are many benefits of renting that can be overshadowed by the allure of buying a home. Here are five reasons why renting might be right for you.
Festive kitchen in Christmas decorations. Christmas dining room....
Lighting Design

6 Holiday Decor Trends to Try in 2022

We've rounded out the top 6 holiday decor trends for 2022 so you can be ahead of the game before you start shopping. 
Happy diverse college or university students are having fun on their graduation day...
BYU MBA at the Marriott School of Business

How to choose what MBA program is right for you: Take this quiz before you apply!

Wondering what MBA program is right for you? Take this quiz before you apply to see if it will help you meet your goals.
Diverse Group of Energetic Professionals Team Meeting in Modern Office: Brainstorming IT Programmer...
Les Olson

Don’t let a ransomware attack get you down | Protect your workplace today with cyber insurance

Business owners and operators should be on guard to protect their workplace. Cyber insurance can protect you from online attacks.
Hand turning a thermostat knob to increase savings by decreasing energy consumption. Composite imag...
Lighting Design

5 Lighting Tips to Save Energy and Money in Your Home

Advances in lighting technology make it easier to use smart features to cut costs. Read for tips to save energy by using different lighting strategies in your home.
Portrait of smiling practitioner with multi-ethnic senior people...
Summit Vista

How retirement communities help with healthy aging

There are many benefits that retirement communities contribute to healthy aging. Learn more about how it can enhance your life, or the life of your loved ones.
House Democrats Investigating Unproven COVID-19 Antibody Tests