Unaffordable Utah: Women Hit Hard By ‘Pink Recession’

Oct 5, 2020, 10:58 PM | Updated: 11:53 pm

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah – Women abandoned the workforce at an alarming pace in September, raising new fears that women are bearing the brunt of the pandemic and that it could have lasting impacts on their careers.

As summer ended and children headed back to the virtual or physical classroom, another shift happened: 865,000 women stopped working or looking for work, accord to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

“Women have disproportionately suffered pandemic-related job losses,” said an analysis of the new jobs report by the National Women’s Law Center.

Four times more women than men left the workforce in September. During that same one-month period, only 216,000 men over the age of 20 dropped out of the labor force.

Uneven Recession

“It has been sudden and severe and uneven,” Natalie Gochnour, director of the Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute at the University of Utah said about the economic downturn. “Some people are calling this a pink collar recession and it’s unusual because normally it’s the men who are hit so hard in recessions, and in this one, it appears to be the women.”

Natalie Gochnour, director of the Kem C. Gardner Policy Institute at the University of Utah. (KSL-TV)

Not only are industries dominated by women losing jobs, but Gochnour said women are also being impacted by disruptions to schooling and increases in household work.

“I want to be really clear, men do these things as well,” she said. “But the research would show that women have taken a larger burden of some of the things inside the home — and we are all inside our homes right now.”

Sixty percent of women in the Beehive State are in the workforce, slightly above the 58% nationwide labor participation rate for women. Of the working women in Utah, 74% have school-aged children.

“Women feel a lot of weight on their shoulders right now and the weight comes from worrying about their children,” Gochnour said. “It comes from the pressures that they feel.”

Kids At Home

“It just turned everything upside down,” said Salt Lake City resident Robynn Garfield about the day that schools closed.

As a journalist for KSL Newsradio, an entrepreneur trying to start her own business and the mother of three boys, Garfield said the pandemic forced the demands of motherhood onto center stage.

“It was an overnight scramble that was almost impossible to do,” she said. “So I had to call into work that day and say, ‘I’m so sorry. My kids are home.’”

With a child with special needs, she worries about fulfilling the role of a specialized educator at home.

As a journalist for KSL Newsradio, an entrepreneur trying to start her own business and the mother of three boys, Robynn Garfield said the pandemic forced the demands of motherhood onto center stage. (KSL-TV)

“Janitor, teacher, principal, therapist, PE teacher, library instructor — that’s me,” Garfield said. “I picked up 15 new job titles overnight the second school went out.”

Six months later, Garfield’s sons were still learning from home because their district hasn’t returned to the physical classroom.

“It all fell on me to either find child care, or quit my job or change my hours or something,” she said.

She emphasized her husband is helping all he can and has adjusted his work schedule on days she needs to go into the office. Even so, she’s had to cut back on hours and feels like her career is being placed on the back burner.

Robynn Garfield works as a journalist for KSL Newsradio. (KSL-TV)

“You can’t walk away from being a mom,” she said. “You can’t get fired or quit. Those hours are there regardless. They’re not flexible. It’s an essential role.”

Long-Term Impact

Garfield knows other mothers who have quit their jobs and worries the strides women have made in the workforce are being washed away by the pandemic.

“We were kind of starting to level that playing field, and now, someone’s handed us a giant weight,” she said.

A recent survey revealed that one in four women are considering either reducing hours or leaving their careers altogether because of COVID-19, according to the 2020 Women in the Workplace report by Lean In and McKinsey and Company.

“This is a critical moment for corporate America,” the report’s authors write. “Companies risk losing women in leadership — and future women leaders — and unwinding years of painstaking progress toward gender diversity.”

The study warns of stalling careers and financial insecurity for women.

“If women leaders leave the workforce, women at all levels could lose their most powerful allies and champions,” the report said.

“For women, we just need more people realizing, ‘Oh, this is all going to fall on you and if we want women in a position of leadership we need to provide you with more support,’” Garfield said.

Child Care Challenges

“It was probably the hardest thing I’ve ever had to do,” Nadia Costa said about being a single mother during the pandemic.

Costa worked as a property manager in Ogden when the pandemic struck and had no childcare options once school closed for her two children.

“I didn’t have family that could help me,” she said. “They weren’t old enough to be left home alone so taking them to work was my only option.”

She said the stress of managing a large apartment complex while also trying to care for her children caused nightly burnout and overwhelming stress.

“I tried my best for as long as I could,” Costa said.

By the time summer arrived, she decided to move across the country to be closer to her significant other and to find more affordable housing.

“I love Utah,” she said. “I love the mountains. I miss them so much but what it came down to was finances.”

She wonders why government resources weren’t there for single parents.

“It’s an impossible thing to expect,” Costa said. “I’m just really, really upset over the fact that we were just overlooked.”

Search For Solutions

“Child care is critical to maintaining employment for the parents,” said Tracy Gruber, director of the Utah Office of Child Care. “And now for many families, we’re asking them to do two full-time jobs.”

Gruber said her office is rushing to expand options for families needing child care during the pandemic.

“They need options for their school-aged children that they never had to contemplate before,” she explained.

Grant money is available to help child care centers increase hours for after school programs.

“This funding will allow them to open all day to serve children on those distance learning days,” Gruber said.

In addition, there is now expanded eligibility for the child care subsidy program to help parents pay for some or all of the cost of child care.

“To working women during COVID, they just got even more put on their shoulders,” Gochnour said.

Communication with their employers is key as women evaluate their options, like temporarily reducing hours, working from home or taking a leave of absence.

“Employers need to be flexible, need to interact and communicate with women and be patient and help them through this,” Gochnour said.

Wise employers, she said, will want to find a way to keep valuable women in their organization.

“If they won’t work with you, go find someone who will,” Gochnour explained. “Because it’s a competitive job market even in these circumstances.”

Gochnour reassured that we are on our way to a slow recovery. In the meantime, she advised working women to be realistic.

“You’re going to have to make some choices. You’re going to have to sacrifice — you can’t do everything,” she said. You’re going to have to prioritize yourself. But in the end, pandemics end. We’ll get through this.”

KSL 5 TV Live

Unaffordable Utah

Wilkerson Farm in Utah County donates grown food to a food bank, shown here on Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2...

Ashley Moser

Utah County farm provides fresh produce to local food pantry

A local food pantry will get more than just canned goods this fall after a Utah County farm looks for a unique way to give back. Wilkerson Farm in Orem partnered with Tabitha’s Way to grow fresh fruits and veggies for families in need.

3 days ago

A sign promoting the new housing project at Liberty Wells Center....

Tamara Vaifanua and Michael Houck, KSL TV

7 new Utah affordable house projects announced

A new development plan could help Utah families struggling to find affordable housing.

4 days ago

File photo of a house for sale...

Tamara Vaifanua

Parents buying homes for their adult children

There’s a surprising growing trend in real estate. Parents and older adults are buying homes for their adult children.

9 days ago

This week on Sunday Edition, Boyd Matheson is joined by Washington Post columnist and author Megan ...


Sunday Edition: Megan McArdle and Moe Egan

This week on Sunday Edition, Boyd Matheson is joined by Washington Post columnist and author Megan McArdle as they examine the obstacles people across the nation are facing to building better lives. Then, the Director of Neighbor Recruitment for The Other Side Village Moe Egan talks about how the village is preparing for its first villagers. And, Boyd shares his thoughts on what makes a village- a place where we all exist- the most valuable.

1 month ago

New townhomes...

Ladd Egan

45 Utahns buy homes in initial week of $20k assistance program

More than $3 million has already been spoken for during the first week of Utah’s new, $20,000 first-time homebuyer assistance program.

2 months ago

Single-family houses...

Bridger Beal-Cvetko, KSL.com and Ladd Egan, KSL TV

Utah releases online tool to make home valuations more transparent

As home prices have risen in recent years, many homeowners have found themselves paying more in property taxes even if their mortgage rate remains the same.

2 months ago

Sponsored Articles

Design mockup half in white and half in color of luxury house interior with open plan living room a...

Lighting Design

Lighting Design 101: Learn the Basics

These lighting design basics will help you when designing your home, so you can meet both practical and aesthetic needs.

an antler with large horns int he wilderness...

Three Bear Lodge

Yellowstone in the Fall: A Wildlife Spectacle Worth Witnessing

While most people travel to this park in the summer, late fall in Yellowstone provides a wealth of highlights to make a memorable experience.

a diverse group of students raising their hands in a classroom...

Little Orchard Preschool

6 Benefits of Preschool for Kids

Some of the benefits of preschool for kids include developing independence, curiosity, and learning more about the world.

rodeo contestant on a saddle bronc...


Get Ready for the Days of ‘47 Rodeo!

The Days of '47 Rodeo is a series of events everyone in the family can enjoy, with world-class rodeo contestants vying for the gold medal.

Electric LED Lightbulb Change In Light At Home...

Lighting Design

How to Know When to Upgrade Your Lighting

This guide explores indicators that suggest it’s time for a lighting upgrade with tips to make an informed decision when you’re ready to buy. 

Brunette guy in headphones playing games on his desktop computer...

PC Laptops

Looking For a New Computer? Use This Desktop Buying Guide

Choosing a new desktop computer can come with a lot of questions, so we created this desktop buying guide.

Unaffordable Utah: Women Hit Hard By ‘Pink Recession’