‘My hands are tied’: Judge rules shooting that endangered child justified under Utah’s new self-defense law

Mar 4, 2022, 10:37 PM | Updated: Jun 19, 2022, 9:44 pm

SALT LAKE CITY – A Utah man successfully urged legislators to pass a law in 2021 that would allow people who claim self-defense to have a chance to get their charges dismissed without going to trial.

Friday, more than a year after his public testimony in support of HB227, the new law worked in Jon Michael Clara’s favor.

A judge dismissed Clara’s 2019 felony weapons case, despite the court’s position that a jury should decide whether Clara was justified when he opened fire on another driver, endangering others nearby after a bizarre crash.

“I believe my hands are tied and I have no choice, given the statute, but to dismiss the case,” said Third District Judge Todd Shaughnessy.

In November, the KSL Investigators first reported on unintended consequences of the controversial new law, a near copy-paste of a Florida statute.

Clara’s support of HB227

“This law, if it were passed, it would help people in my situation,” Clara told lawmakers during a legislative committee hearing in February 2021.

Jon Michael Clara (left) and defense attorney Clayton Simms (right) participate in a virtual hearing on March 4, 2022.

The Legislature passed HB227, and it went into effect in May, triggering a new pre-trial process for cases in which the accused claims self-defense.

Under HB227, prosecutors must now prove by clear and convincing evidence in a pre-trial hearing that the defendant did not act in self-defense or in the defense of others. If prosecutors cannot prove that an individual’s use of force was not justified during the justification hearing before a trial, the case is dismissed before it ever goes to a jury.

The new law went into effect on May 5, 2021. Clara filed a motion for a justification hearing on May 7.

Clara’s June trial was cancelled and the justification hearing, which was initially scheduled for July, was pushed back to November.

Case background

Clara faced seven felony counts of discharging a firearm after shooting at a blue truck with a snowplow that repeatedly crashed into the Toyota 4Runner Clara was driving on Nov. 23, 2019.

A blue truck with a snowplow rammed into an SUV multiple times, spinning it around to face oncoming traffic on Nov. 23, 2019.

According to a probable cause statement, “CLARA stated he got out of the Toyota and started shooting because he thought the truck was going to turn around. CLARA stated he was aiming at the pavement towards the back of the truck to keep it away.”

One of the bullets flew through the cab of an uninvolved third vehicle, a truck that was stopped nearby as drivers in the area waited for a train to pass.

According to the document, a man reported hearing glass break as the bullet entered through a rear window and exited through the windshield. The man was seated in the driver seat, his wife was in the front passenger seat and the couple’s 12-year-old daughter was sitting in the back seat. No one was injured, but the child had several pieces of broken glass in her hair.

The blue truck with the snowplow was later found crashed and abandoned. The owner told police it had been stolen, and investigators never identified the driver.

Justification hearing

During the November evidentiary hearing to address the issue of self-defense, Clara recounted what he remembers from that day, telling the court, “I was just aiming to let him know, if you come back this way, you know, you’re going to get shot.”

Clara and his passenger both testified that they saw brake lights as the truck stopped. Clara said it started to turn right toward nearby businesses.

The crash and subsequent shooting happened near 900 West and 100 South in Salt Lake County on Nov. 23, 2019.

He insisted he was in fear for his life and felt he was acting in defense of himself and his passenger.

“The other thing I was worried about is if he turned all the way around, he has this, this snowplow thing in front of him that acts like his bulletproof shield,” Clara said. “So, you know, if he turned all the way around, then I wouldn’t have been able to do anything for myself or my passenger.”

Case dismissed

Friday, during a scheduled hearing for arguments and a ruling on the issue of justification, Judge Shaughnessy asked questions of both attorneys regarding the distance of the blue truck from Clara and how it was positioned when Clara started shooting.

“It’s my understanding that whatever laser beam or whatever the officers were using, wasn’t functioning,” said defense attorney Clayton Simms. “So, in terms of an exact measurement from the police, we don’t have that.”

As for the position of the vehicle prosecutor Spencer Wyatt argued, “Whether it’s broadside or facing away, it wasn’t facing towards the defendant. And it had not been turned around.”

Shaughnessy also asked whether he should consider the evidence of a stray bullet endangering a nearby family. The defense argued that information is irrelevant to the issue of whether Clara’s use of force was justified.

“If the shot is permissible that’s the only question, not where it ended up,” said Simms. “He can lawfully shoot at the vehicle that’s attacking him. It’s unfortunate that it hits hit someone else rather than that target, but if it’s self-defense, then that will extend to whatever vehicle it hit.”

Wyatt argued that Clara was not in imminent danger and did not act in self-defense, but rather his actions were fueled by adrenaline, and he was upset by the traffic collision.

“Frankly, if this kind of behavior is allowed and legally justifiable, then we’re living in the Thunderdome with Mad Max,” he said.

Third District Judge Todd Shaughnessy presiding over a hearing in Clara’s case on March 4, 2022.

The judge said he could see the outcome of the case going either way if it were presented to a jury.

“This case is, in the court’s view, a classic case that should be decided by a jury,” said Shaughnessy. “And in the absence of this statute that shifts the burden to the state, this case would be presented to a jury and a jury would decide.”

But under Utah’s new law, Shaughnessy had to decide whether the state had met its burden of clear and convincing evidence in its claim that Clara did not act in self-defense or the defense of others.

“As much as it troubles me to hear a story about a young child who is almost killed in the backseat of their car as they’re traveling down the street, my hands are tied by the requirements that the Legislature imposed in the new statute,” he said.

Shaughnessy encouraged the state to appeal his decision. Appeals must be filed within 30 days, and the Utah Attorney General’s Office is the only agency that can appeal felony cases.

Have you experienced something you think just isn’t right? The KSL Investigators want to help. Submit your tip at investigates@ksl.com or 385-707-6153 so we can get working for you.

Related Stories:

KSL 5 TV Live

KSL Investigates

FILE: Credit and deposit cards on a computer keyboard. Electronic commerce, business. Online shoppi...

Matt Gephardt and Sloan Schrage

Utah family says their bank refuses to reimburse fraudulent charges

A Taylorsville family says a hacker drained thousands of dollars out of their bank accounts and left them overdrawn by tens of thousands more. They thought federal banking rules protected them, but they say their bank has refused to reimburse them for those losses.

13 hours ago

Judge Patrick Corum hears arguments about Attorney General Sean Reyes’ work calendar on Monday, F...

Annie Knox and Daniella Rivera

Judge to rule if public gets to see Utah attorney general’s work calendar

KSL and the Utah Attorney General’s Office squared off in court over whether the A.G.’s calendar should be publicly available.

15 hours ago

(KSL TV)...

Annie Knox and Daniella Rivera

5 things to know about KSL’s legal fight for transparency

How much should Utahns get to know about how elected officials spend their time on the clock? The question is at the center of a legal fight taking KSL to court Monday.

1 day ago

Homeowner Mark Shea tells KSL’s Matt Gephardt he paid someone to build a deck who abandoned the j...

Matt Gephardt

Get Gephardt: Homeowners ask why authorities can’t shut down an unlicensed contractor

Two Salt Lake County homeowners hired and paid someone to build decks for their homes but say he left the jobs unfinished. Turns out, he’s been cited by the state for not having a contractor’s license before.

5 days ago

Senate President Stuart Adams, R-Layton, and Sen. Curt Bramble, R-Provo, react to a reporter’s qu...

Daniella Rivera and Annie Knox, KSL TV

‘More secrecy’: Utah lawmakers advance bills targeting government transparency

Several bills would chip away at government transparency in Utah, including one proposal that’s a direct response to KSL’s fight for public records. A First Amendment attorney says he’s alarmed.

5 days ago

Matt Gephardt, journalists, looks as paper with a woman...

Matt Gephardt and Cimaron Neugebauer

Get Gephardt: Ticketmaster seizes back purchased seats

Imagine buying tickets to a show, then having the seller refuse to give them to you. That’s what happened to a Utah woman, when she got a refund she didn’t ask for.

6 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Modern chandelier hanging from a white slanted ceiling with windows in the backgruond...

Lighting Design

Light Up Your Home With These Top Lighting Trends for 2024

Check out the latest lighting design trends for 2024 and tips on how you can incorporate them into your home.

Technician woman fixing hardware of desktop computer. Close up....

PC Laptops

Tips for Hassle-Free Computer Repairs

Experiencing a glitch in your computer can be frustrating, but with these tips you can have your computer repaired without the stress.

Close up of finger on keyboard button with number 11 logo...

PC Laptops

7 Reasons Why You Should Upgrade Your Laptop to Windows 11

Explore the benefits of upgrading to Windows 11 for a smoother, more secure, and feature-packed computing experience.

Stylish room interior with beautiful Christmas tree and decorative fireplace...

Lighting Design

Create a Festive Home with Our Easy-to-Follow Holiday Prep Guide

Get ready for festive celebrations! Discover expert tips to prepare your home for the holidays, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere for unforgettable moments.

Battery low message on mobile device screen. Internet and technology concept...

PC Laptops

9 Tips to Get More Power Out of Your Laptop Battery

Get more power out of your laptop battery and help it last longer by implementing some of these tips from our guide.

Users display warnings about the use of artificial intelligence (AI), access to malicious software ...

Les Olson

How to Stay Safe from Cybersecurity Threats

Read our tips for reading for how to respond to rising cybersecurity threats in 2023 and beyond to keep yourself and your company safe.

‘My hands are tied’: Judge rules shooting that endangered child justified under Utah’s new self-defense law