Tracking similarities in transgender sports bans across the country

Apr 14, 2022, 7:11 AM | Updated: Jun 19, 2022, 10:00 pm

SALT LAKE CITY – After learning about two transgender sprinters winning girls’ races on the other side of the country four years ago, Idaho Rep. Barbara Ehardt got to work.

The Republican lawmaker and basketball coach of more than 30 years said she feared cisgender girls in her own state could lose out if the state didn’t step in to restrict transgender athletes’ participation in school sports.

“Gosh, somebody should do something,” she remembers thinking. “And it dawned on me that I was the person that could do something.”

But she needed help navigating the legal nitty-gritty, so she consulted the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), she said. Eventually, the Arizona-based conservative Christian legal group decided to play a bigger role in her effort, she told the KSL investigators, sending her a model bill its attorneys drafted.

The measure passed in 2020, becoming the nation’s first law banning transgender girls in school sports. Other states, including Utah, were quick to follow. Fifteen now have bans in place, although some are on hold because of lawsuits.

A national wave   

The proposals have cropped up in a total of 38 states, with many mirroring much of Ehardt’s measure.

To analyze just how closely they align with the original Idaho law, the KSL Investigators compared them using software designed to check for plagiarism.

We found one bill introduced in West Virginia, for example, is nearly a carbon copy, at a 95% match. The state ultimately passed a different version that had less in common – 9% — with the Idaho law. But like Idaho, it cited “inherent differences” between men and women as “cause for celebration.”

Similarities across several states include other word-for-word references to traits like lung volume and testosterone, and other statements about differences in biology. Many include notes about prior court cases and include a basis for cisgender players to sue if their school doesn’t follow the law and they believe they’ve been deprived of an opportunity.

Overall, the KSL Investigators found versions of bills in six states that were at least a 50% match to Idaho’s bill, in addition to West Virginia: Florida (54%), Kansas (65%), New Jersey (80%), North Carolina (66%) Rhode Island (73%) and Mississippi (77%).

Some of the measures we analyzed using Copyscape’s program were later revised, and not all similarities were apparent due to punctuation or numbering on the bills.

We found 12 states with measures that had less than 5% in common with Idaho, including Alabama and Connecticut, which both had zero matching phrases. Eight more states ranged in the 5%-20% zone, five more hovered in the 20-29% realm, and another five varied from 30-46%.

Utah’s unsuccessful 2021 proposal was just a 9% match to Idaho, and the rate dropped lower for the 2022 version set to go into effect in July, which had almost no word-for-word similarities.

Rep. Kera Birkeland, R-Morgan, who sponsored the Utah measures, said ADF sent her a model bill, but as she hammered out details and negotiated with advocates and others, it underwent drastic changes. For example, Birkeland, a high school girls basketball coach, says she wanted to allow transgender kids to be practice players for girls’ teams, while ADF’s version did not. 

Rep. Kera Birkeland, R-Morgan, the sponsor of HB11 Student Eligibility in Interscholastic Activities, speaks at a hearing Monday. The bill would appoint a commission to decide if transgender kids can play sports. (Scott G. Winterton, Deseret News)

Last year, Ehardt testified in favor of Birkeland’s bill and others in Montana and South Dakota.

When lawmakers in other states got in touch, Ehardt said she referred them to ADF for help with tricky legal questions.

She described the organization as “hugely helpful, especially when it comes to the legality. They cross their t’s and dot their i’s, and it’s just simply something that legislators can’t do.”

Outside influence 

The group is part of a coalition called Promise to America’s Children, which also includes the conservative American Principles Project and Eagle Forum, among others. The coalition backs bills like Ehardt’s, and its website offers to send model bills to lawmakers.

Political scientist Matthew Burbank says it’s no secret that legislators don’t always craft their own proposals, and groups from both the political left and right often draw up proposals to pitch.

“You kind of think, well, that’s odd that, you know, both Alabama and Utah and North Dakota are all debating the same piece of legislation,” Burbank said. “And almost always it’s coming through those channels of somebody pushing model legislation.” 

For example, he said, organizations like the conservative American Legislative Exchange Council often draft model bills focused on issues like taxes or technology.

In recent years, however, more proposals tied to social issues have surfaced, he said, and many have sailed through overwhelmingly Republican statehouses.

But it can be difficult to know who is backing the efforts.

KSL+: Unpacking HB11 and the debate surrounding transgender athletes

Unlike political campaigns, organizations pushing legislation aren’t required by law to disclose exactly where the money comes from, Burbank noted.

ADF didn’t answer KSL’s questions about how many states it worked with on the bills. But a spokeswoman emphasized that it’s common for lawmakers to ask groups from across the political spectrum for feedback on bills.

The organization raised about $65 million in 2020, tax returns show. And it does more than help write legislation.  

ADF also gets involved in court cases. The group intervened in lawsuits over the legislation now on hold in Idaho and West Virginia, and previously it represented a Colorado baker who refused to make a cake for a gay couple in 2012.

“ADF is regularly invited to draw upon our constitutional expertise to provide input into forthcoming bills,” the nonprofit said in a statement, adding it has argued several cases before the U.S. Supreme Court.

The bans on transgender students in sports are characterized by emotional debate. Supporters say they’re needed to guarantee an even playing field because of the potential physical advantages some transgender girls could have.

“These girls have a right under Title IX to compete with a fair playing field,” Birkeland said, referring to the federal law barring discrimination based on sex in schools.

But opponents say the legislation is unconstitutional and discriminatory. While Utah’s new law is focused on school sports, more is at stake, according to Gillian Branstetter, press secretary for the National Women’s Law Center in Washington, DC. 

“This is critically, an effort to keep the door open towards more harsh penalties,” Branstetter said. “Exclusion of transgender girls from sports helps the very extreme movement that is doing far, far worse harms to transgender people.”

Birkeland said she sees it differently.  

“It’s not discriminatory by nature to say if you want to play our sport, you’re absolutely welcome to try out, and here’s the team that you must try out for,” she said.  

A last-minute change

After the 2021 bill failed, politicians and advocates spent about a year negotiating. They hammered out a compromise that would create a commission to determine a transgender student’s eligibility to play a sport.  

The plan fell apart in the last hours of the 2022 session after Birkeland says only an all-out ban had the support to pass.  

After a year of negotiating behind the scenes, Troy Williams with Equality Utah said the last-minute change did not fit with Utah’s collegial style of politics often referred to as the “Utah Way.”  

Lawmakers override Cox veto, ban transgender athletes in high school sports

He says several Republican lawmakers called him up with a similar message. 

“I hate this bill,” he recalled them saying. “I don’t want to vote for it. But the county convention is coming up, and I’m fearing for my political seat.” 

Williams noted four transgender students in Utah play sports and just one is a girl. He says they deserve the same opportunities as their classmates.  

“It’s moral panic, it’s hysteria, and it’s cruel,” he said of the law.   

Birkeland believes Utahns had ample opportunity to express their views.   

“We had a whole year-plus of discussion of what would a ban look like and how far — how extensive — would that ban be,” she said. 

After Gov. Spencer Cox vetoed the measure with an impassioned rebuke, lawmakers overrode the Republican governor’s veto. The law takes effect July 1.  

Emiley Morgan and Daniella Rivera contributed research.   

Have you experienced something you think just isn’t right? The KSL Investigators want to help. Submit your tip at investigates@ksl.com or 385-707-6153 so we can get working for you.

KSL 5 TV Live

KSL Investigates

FILE: Jay Schmidt shows the texts between himself and a scammer....

Matt Gephardt and Sloan Schrage

Fraudster impersonates Gov. Cox, asks for gift cards

A fraudster impersonated Gov. Cox, trying to swindle others into buying gift cards.

2 days ago

Car mirror with credit score in it...

Matt Gephardt and Cindy St. Clair, KSL TV

Despite on-time payments, woman’s credit score drops due to company not reporting

A Box Elder County woman bought a car and made payments on time to boost her credit scores. It did the opposite. Matt Gephardt investigates what went wrong.

2 days ago

Medical bill...

Matt Gephardt & Sloan Schrage

Lehi man says medical clinic refuses to work with his faith-based medical cost sharing plan

Miles is the newest member of the Littledike family. His father, Ryan, says Miles’ arrival in December went almost flawlessly.

4 days ago

Wendie Muhic is the frustrated owner of a 2007 Chevy Tahoe, that dies a lot....

Matt Gephardt & Sloan Schrage

West Jordan car owner says odometer fraud has left her stuck paying thousands on a lemon she can’t drive

Wendie Muhic is the frustrated owner of a 2007 Chevy Tahoe that dies a lot. Now she is left paying for it.

9 days ago

Woman texting...

Matt Gephardt

How crooks use texts to get your money, identity, or both.

If you used a mobile phone for any length of time, it’s likely you have gotten text messages that seem like an honest mistake that innocuous-looking text might have come from a scammer.

10 days ago


Daniella Rivera and Keira Fairmont

Treat and Release: How Utah weighs the risk of repeat sex offenders

The KSL Investigators examine Utah’s corrections system, responsible for treating and releasing people who commit sex crimes.

10 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Brunette guy in headphones playing games on his desktop computer...

PC Laptops

Looking For a New Computer? Use This Desktop Buying Guide

Choosing a new desktop computer can come with a lot of questions, so we created this desktop buying guide.

Portrait of happy boy playing and splashing water in the swimming pool...

Get Out Pass

Family Fun Activities in Utah You Have to Try This Summer

These family fun activities will entertain you all summer, so if you ever feel stuck in a rut wondering what to do, refer to this guide!

Woman IT specialist in elegant suit working on notebook computer in data center next to server rack...

Les Olson

Your Complete Guide to Outsourcing IT Services

This guide covers everything you need to know about the different benefits of outsourcing IT services to meet your small business needs.

diverse group of friends dance outside under string lights...

Lighting Design

5 Frequently Asked Questions About Outdoor Lighting

Read for the most frequently asked questions about outdoor lighting to help narrow the search for your home.

Stack of old laptops with dark background...

PC Laptops

Old Laptop Upgrades You Need to Try Before Throwing it Away

Get the most out of your investment. Try these old laptop upgrades before throwing it out to keep it running fast and efficient.

Happy diverse college or university students are having fun on their graduation day...

BYU MBA at the Marriott School of Business

How to Choose What MBA Program is Right for You: Take this Quiz Before You Apply!

Wondering what MBA program is right for you? Take this quiz before you apply to see if it will help you meet your goals.

Tracking similarities in transgender sports bans across the country