LOCAL NEWS

Why Salt Lake City is weighing a decision that other ‘big four’ sports cities are facing

Jul 2, 2024, 10:07 AM | Updated: 10:11 am

A draft rendering of what a plaza outside of the Delta Center could look like in downtown Salt Lake...

A draft rendering of what a plaza outside of the Delta Center could look like in downtown Salt Lake City. The Salt Lake City Council is expected to vote on a partnership next week. (Smith Entertainment Group)

(Smith Entertainment Group)

SALT LAKE CITY — The Salt Lake City Council is expected to vote soon on whether to partner with Smith Entertainment Group and advance plans to remodel the Delta Center and create a “sports, entertainment, culture and convention district” surrounding it.

City leaders offered a slight update to negotiations on Friday, noting that talks between all sides will carry through the Fourth of July with a “possible vote” on July 9. The council has until September to vote on an agreement, per the state law approved this year that set up the process. That’s also about when an associated 0.5% sales tax increase needs to be voted on.

Both votes would come after a pair of public hearings on the matter that produced dozens of comments split into all sorts of directions, ranging from outright opposition to spending public money on the project to supporting efforts to improve downtown Salt Lake City.

But Salt Lake City certainly isn’t alone in these types of decisions. At least three similar stadium votes were handed down among cities with “big four” sports leagues within the past month alone.

Recent stadium votes in the US

  • The Jacksonville, Florida, City Council voted 14-1 on June 25 to approve a $1.45 billion funding package to modernize EverBank Stadium, the home of the Jacksonville Jaguars, the Jacksonville Daily Record reported.
  • The Charlotte, North Carolina, City Council voted 7-3 on June 24 to commit $650 million toward renovating Bank of America Stadium, the home of the Carolina Panthers, according to the Charlotte Observer.
  • Kansas Gov. Laura Kelly signed a bill on June 21 that could finance up to 70% of the cost should the Kansas City Chiefs and/or Kansas City Royals relocate across the border from Missouri, according to the Missouri Independent. Jackson County, Missouri, voters rejected a stadium tax measure that would have funded renovations or new stadiums back in April.
  • Gov. Spencer Cox signed two bills in March that set up the framework for public financing that can be used for stadiums in Salt Lake City. One centers around the Utah Jazz and Hockey Club; the other focuses on a possible Major League Baseball stadium near the Utah State Fairpark.
  • Tempe, Arizona, residents rejected a $2.3 billion sports-entertainment district proposal for the Arizona Coyotes in May 2023.

So, why is it that state and local governments are faced with having to vote on whether to offer public funds for massive projects?

Governments and stadiums

Experts say there are various reasons as to why public financing has become so prevalent in sports, and why Salt Lake City is now in the middle of this debate.

On one hand, stadiums are expensive, especially if a project tries to incorporate more than just a stadium.

Smith Entertainment Group’s arena vision calls for it to be remodeled so it can accommodate both the Utah Jazz and Utah Hockey Club. It would also completely reimagine downtown Salt Lake City by cutting into the Salt Palace Convention Center and creating a connection between a remodeled Delta Center and entertainment, culture and convention spaces east of it.

In return, it’s asking for a 99-year lease for the Delta Center land and for Salt Lake City to approve a 0.5% sales tax increase with a cap of $900 million that it could collect over the next 30 years.

A project could bring a type of community value worthy of public funding, says Keven Rowe, a shareholder of the business law firm Buchalter. In this case, he believes the plan could liven up a section of the city that struggles because the convention center essentially divides downtown in half by covering up 100 South.

“There’s a pretty compelling story that it adds to the economic prosperity of the city or an area — and there’s a justification for asking for public participation,” he told KSL.com. “I think that’s why there’s a partnership, and it’s got the momentum to happen because it’s a win-win for both the city and SEG (Smith Entertainment Group).”

On the other hand, there are only a finite number of “big four” professional sports teams — NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL — in North America, and the number of markets that could support a franchise outnumbers the number of teams.

That makes it easier for a team owner to find another city willing to offer incentives. David Berri, a professor of economics at Southern Utah University and former president of the North American Association of Sports Economists, explains that most relocations ultimately boil down to this.

That includes the Utah Hockey Club, although with a bit of a twist. The NHL stepped in to help facilitate the sale and relocation of the Arizona Coyotes when its ownership failed to provide a viable stadium after Tempe, Arizona’s 2023 vote.

If a franchise is valuable to the city or state, Berri says those communities often have to pony up the money to keep it from relocating when stadium requests emerge.

“A team can go to cities and say, ‘If you don’t build me a stadium, I’ll bounce to another city,'” he said.

What is the public benefit of stadiums?

Berri, Rowe and many other experts agree that sports provide benefits to communities, but there’s no consensus as to what those benefits are.

Rowe points to developmental success in places like San Francisco and Seattle, which turned around dead warehouse-centric areas in each city with stadiums that ultimately spurred development around them. Blending more than just sports into a stadium is a model that he believes “works for everybody” because it can fuel growth. That’s something he sees in the Salt Lake City plan.

“Creating a corridor between the Delta Center and Main Street would be great for the city,” he said, adding that it could eliminate a “dead spot” created by the Salt Palace’s size.

University of Utah’s Kem C. Gardner Institute projects that the Delta Center will generate an annual economic impact of over $600 million with the Jazz, Hockey Club and other events. Natalie Gochnour, the institute’s director, told members of the Salt Lake City Council on June 11 that sports, entertainment, culture and conventions are also key influencers in a strong downtown, drawing people into the region.

However, Gochnour said the bigger impact could be the downtown investments surrounding the arena.

“We’ve still got a chance of holding onto a great American city because of investment,” she said, noting that downtown Salt Lake City’s population declined in 1960 and only turned around in the 1990s when public investments were made to improve its layout and infrastructure.

Berri isn’t as confident about the economic impacts. He sums up several studies that found the same thing: There’s little evidence that stadiums significantly boost an economy. For instance, a study published in the Journal of Urban Affairs two years ago found that Truist Park near Atlanta offered “limited economic impact” to Cobb County, Georgia, despite its “favorable location and ancillary mixed-use development.”

That’s because most people don’t have an infinite budget with unlimited money they can spend on entertainment, Berri explains. If people spend money on the Utah Hockey Club, they might go to fewer Jazz games, movies or restaurants to compensate. That’s where the benefit is curbed.

So what do economists with this viewpoint believe stadiums are good for? Well, sports can build communities and make residents happy — especially when a team is winning. Berri says that’s a benefit that could be worth the public investment.

“Cities do fund things that make people happy; sports do make people happy. We build public parks; they make people happy,” he said. “It’s not necessarily a bad thing. In this case, a billionaire is getting something that they could pay for themselves … and that can make people unhappy.”

The Salt Lake City Council will have to consider all of these different thoughts as it votes next week. And barring an unforeseen change in the North American sports structure, these are the types of considerations that U.S. cities with a “big four” sports franchise may have to consider every time there’s a stadium situation.

KSL 5 TV Live

Local News

FILE — Utah Highway Patrol vehicle. (KSLTV.com)...

Carlysle Price

One in critical condition following head-on crash in Summit County

One person is in critical condition after two vehicles crashed head-on Wednesday night.

3 hours ago

FILE — A state panel has ruled in favor of transparency again, ordering the AG’s office to tur...

Annie Knox, Daniella Rivera and Courtney Johns, KSL TV

First glance at the AG’s calendar: What is — and isn’t — inside

As part of a settlement agreement, the Utah Attorney General’s Office released thousands of pages of Sean Reyes’ work calendar to KSL. The release of the records brings an end to a nearly two-year legal effort by Reyes and his office to conceal the records from the public.

4 hours ago

Fire crews conducted a controlled burn in Wellsville on Oct. 30, 2024, on two buildings ready for d...

Jacob Freeman

Fire crews use controlled burn to demolish Wellsville buildings

Fire departments in the Cache County Fire District conducted a controlled burn of two residential buildings in Mendon last week.

5 hours ago

FILE — President Joe Biden speaks from the South Lawn of the White House in Washington, Monday, ...

KSL TV

Church leaders congratulate Trump, thank Harris and Biden

The First Presidency and the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints issued a statement after the United States presidential election.

5 hours ago

Bar-W Beef, pictured in Nephi on Wednesday, Nov. 6, 2024, had its grand opening the previous week. ...

Alex Cabrero

Idea for new beef processing plant in Nephi began during covid meat shortages

There sure are a lot of cows in Utah. Farms with rich agricultural histories are located throughout the state.

6 hours ago

The Utah County Clerk is now responding to Tuesday's ballot issues, that led to long lines at the b...

Brian Carlson

Utah County Clerk responds to criticism over Election Day issues

The Utah County Clerk is now responding to Tuesday's ballot issues, that led to long lines at the ballot box and compelled the state to send a plane to pick up ballots during the middle of Election Day.

6 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

abstract vector digital social network technology background...

Les Olson

Protecting yourself against social engineering attacks

Learn more about the common types of social engineering to protect your online or offline assets from an attack.

family having fun at home...

Lighting Design

Discover the impact of lighting on your mood

From color temperature to lighting saturation, we tackle how different lighting design setups can impact your day-to-day mood.

Laptops in a modern technology store. Department of computers in the electronics store. Choosing a ...

PC Laptops

How to choose the best laptop for college students

Finding the right laptop for college students can be hard, but with this guide we break down what to look for so you can find the best one.

young male technician is repairing a printer at office...

Les Olson

Unraveling the dilemma between leasing and buying office technology

Carefully weigh these pros and cons to make an informed decision that best suits your business growth and day-to-day operation. 

A kitchen in a modern farmhouse....

Lighting Design

A room-by-room lighting guide for your home

Bookmark this room-by-room lighting guide whenever you decide to upgrade your lighting or style a new home.

Photo courtesy of Artists of Ballet West...

Ballet West

The rising demand for ballet tickets: why they’re harder to get

Ballet West’s box office is experiencing demand they’ve never seen before, leaving many interested patrons unable to secure tickets they want.

Why Salt Lake City is weighing a decision that other ‘big four’ sports cities are facing