LOCAL NEWS

Ryan Smith teases reimagined downtown SLC with new arena as lawmakers debate billions in subsidies

Feb 27, 2024, 12:05 PM | Updated: Jul 1, 2024, 6:27 am

Ryan Smith posted this image to X on Tuesday, showing a new NBA and NHL arena anchoring what he cal...

Ryan Smith posted this image to X on Tuesday, showing a new NBA and NHL arena anchoring what he called a revitalized downtown Salt Lake City. (Ryan Smith, X)

(Ryan Smith, X)

SALT LAKE CITY — Utah Jazz governor Ryan Smith took to social media on Tuesday, posting a rendering of a reimagined downtown Salt Lake City sports and entertainment district, anchored by a new arena that would host the Jazz and a potential National Hockey League franchise.

The image comes as state lawmakers discuss giving Smith upward of $1 billion through a 0.5% sales tax increase in Salt Lake City to partially fund the arena. Another bill would give the Larry H. Miller Group nearly the same amount for a potential Major League Baseball stadium just across Interstate 15, in the Fairpark neighborhood.

“Downtown Salt Lake City is the heart of Utah,” Smith said in his post. “Our efforts are not about an arena, it’s about revitalizing a downtown that desperately needs investment. Imagine a downtown experience like this with the NBA / NHL at its core.”

The Legislature has until Friday night to pass any bills in this year’s general session.

Smith formally asked the NHL last month to begin the expansion process to bring a franchise to the Beehive State. He said a team could immediately play in the Delta Center, with a franchise moving into “a new, state-of-the-art hockey arena” in the next several years.

Revitalizing downtown or redistributing tax dollars?

While Smith points to revitalizing downtown Salt Lake, economists broadly agree that arenas are “not economic development catalysts and confer limited social benefits.”

“It’s really across the board that these are really poor public investments,” said J.C. Bradbury, a Kennesaw State University economics professor who studies sports economics and stadium subsidies.

Ryan Smith Teases New Downtown Arena Rendering Focused On Pro Sports Arena

Bradbury, along with Dennis Coates, an economic professor at the University of Maryland, Baltimore; and Brad Humphreys, an economic professor at West Virginia University, published a comprehensive review of stadium policy just last year.

They noted that “research continues to demonstrate that stadiums remain poor public investments, and optimal public funding of professional sports venues is substantially less than typical subsidy levels.”

In their article, they looked at several recent sports and entertainment districts, including Baltimore’s Camden Yards (MLB), Cleveland district of Progressive Field (MLB) and next-door neighbor Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse (NBA), San Diego’s Petco Park (MLB), Denver’s Coors Field (MLB) and Atlanta’s highly touted Truist Park (MLB) and “The Battery Atlanta.”

Economic reviews of those projects noted “very localized success” in Baltimore, “a net drain” on San Diego taxpayers, Cleveland’s project thriving at the expense of other parts of its downtown and development in Denver occurring away from the ballpark.

In 2015, a decade after San Diego opened Petco Park, about $14 million – roughly 8% of city tourism taxes – was being funneled toward stadium operations and related bond payments.

Bradbury wrote that sales tax revenue in Cobb County, Georgia, increased when it opened a new stadium for the Atlanta Braves in 2017; but, “the magnitude of the effect is small and not statistically significant” and wasn’t enough to offset the subsidies local officials provided, a study published in the Journal of Urban Affairs in 2022 states.

Atlanta’s project has since run an annual deficit of $12 million to $15 million for Cobb County, which committed to financing $300 million to help with construction of the stadium.

Their overall conclusion?

“The widespread belief that placing stadiums in urban environments can redevelop urban areas to promote new economic activity is mostly anecdotal and lacks strong empirical support.”

Ideally, the government shouldn’t get involved with professional sports but with at least two other cities also petitioning for expansion teams, it will likely have to happen in some form, says David Berri, a professor of economics at Southern Utah University and former president of the North American Association of Sports Economists.

“The problem that Salt Lake City is going to have is, if they want a team, they’re going to have to subsidize this,” he told KSL.com. “Baseball is going to demand something from them because they have choices. … (MLB doesn’t) create as many teams as they could have and that way, markets are left open.”

Salt Lake City Mayor Erin Mendenhall voiced her support for the proposal, presenting the NHL bill alongside its sponsor Sen. Dan McCay, R-Riverton.

“We set the pulse of the state in downtown Salt Lake City — for our economy, culture, sports and entertainment,” Mendenhall said Tuesday. “Our downtown and the investment in it must remain strong to ensure we have a future with a better quality of life for residents and deepening community connections.”

Last Thursday, a Senate committee advanced the plan to fund the NHL stadium and downtown sports and entertainment district, which includes a sales tax increase of up to 0.5% in Salt Lake City.

“It is with this abundance of caution that we ask the people of Utah to invest in a project like this, that we know long-term, generational investment is to the benefit of not only those here today, but we look forward cheering on the Jazz and the National Hockey League,” McCay said.

What about just taxing people who use the stadium?

Funding for the MLB had been focused on a hotel tax, which raised concerns among Utah’s hotel industry because hotel taxes across the state would go up — not just around the stadium. On Tuesday, lawmakers said they would strip out the statewide hotel tax portion of the bill.

If the bill had passed in that version, hotel taxes would have gone up one-tenth of a percent immediately upon Gov. Spencer Cox’s signature. Lawmakers say that would help fund emergency services largely needed for tourism in rural Utah.

Then, once a team is secured, hotel taxes would go up by a total of 1.5%. That amounts to $3 per night on a $200-per-night hotel stay. Car rental tax would also go up an additional 1.5%.

“Our fear is that as more and more taxes get layered onto the transient room tax, the more difficult it is to be to sell rooms, and at some point, hoteliers are going to have to adjust their rates in order to compensate for that tax increase,” Jordan Garn, a representative for the Utah Hotel and Lodging Association, told KSL TV’s Lindsay Aerts.

Garn said that the association is very excited about major league baseball but still worried that the hotel tax hike falls on Utahns.

“The general consensus is that out-of-state residents are paying for this. That’s not necessarily entirely true. We know that about half of hotel stays in Utah are paid for by people that reside in Utah,” Garn said. “And so the more they start to lean on not only affects Utah consumers, but it’s also ultimately going to have an impact on the industry itself.”

Bradbury, Coates and Humphreys noted this wouldn’t be the first time cities claim to turn to non-residents to fund projects. Houston funds its major league venues through 2% hotel and 5% rental car taxes. After a hotel tax passed to fund a new NFL stadium for the Atlanta Falcons, the city’s mayor said the revenue would come “almost exclusively…from visitors and tourists,” not local residents.

They would agree with Garn and noted in their study that it’s “incorrect to view hotel and rental car taxes as being assessed on stadium patrons” as the majority of fans at an MLB game in SLC would be local residents who do not stay in hotels, and the vast majority of hotel and car rental customers in the state would not be attending baseball games.

A special district tax also appears to be a use tax, where taxes are only paid by people in the district to be used for the upkeep of the stadium and surrounding areas. However, the authors noted that local residents would make up the majority of the district’s customers, meaning money spent in the district is just reallocated from spending at existing local businesses. A family eating dinner at a new restaurant next to the stadium keeps those tax dollars in the district, whereas eating at an established restaurant outside the district generates tax revenue to support public services.

“The broader lesson is that sports stadiums do not have a broad economic impact, so why do we keep talking about them like they do?” Bradbury asked.

KSL 5 TV Live

Local News

Autumn Mercado, who was found dead in her home on Monday, Jan. 13, 2025....

Garna Mejia

Charges pending in case of West Jordan mother found dead, family seeks justice and protection for children

Nearly a month after the discovery of a West Jordan woman's body during a welfare check, charges in the case have yet to be filed.

6 hours ago

FILE - A police vehicle flashes its lights. (Matt Rourke, Associated Press) FILE: police lights. On...

Michael Houck

Pedestrian killed after being hit by a vehicle, Santa Clara-Ivins police say

A woman was fatally hit by a vehicle Friday evening, Santa Clara-Ivins police say.

6 hours ago

An Orem home that was scheduled to be demolished on fire on Feb. 4, 2025....

Brian Carlson

Massive Orem house fire being investigated as arson

A fire that destroyed an empty Orem home in a wooded area of the city is now being investigated as arson.

7 hours ago

Nancy Duncan and Nick Jenderko behind Sabrina Carpenter at the 2025 Grammy Awards show....

Mike Anderson

Utahns sat among stars at the Grammys

Some Utahns earned some bragging rights after a night at the Grammy Awards.

8 hours ago

FILE: On the same day the Utah’s Senate unanimously passed a resolution to bring an NHL franchise...

Daniella Rivera

‘You are inviting rapists to Utah’: Survivor urges lawmakers to consider consent bill

Year after year, Utah lawmakers have resisted or ignored efforts to close what experts and advocates say is a gap in the state’s sexual assault laws. The lawmaker behind those efforts hopes this year will be different.

9 hours ago

Over a thousand people filled the state Capitol rotunda Friday pleading for Gov. Spencer Cox to vet...

Shara Park

Thousands gather at Capitol Hill to protest against controversial union bill

Over a thousand people filled the Utah State Capitol rotunda Friday pleading for Gov. Spencer Cox to veto HB267.

9 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

holiday gift basket with blue tissue paper and gingerbread cookies...

Kneaders Bakery & Cafe

Holiday hacks for a stress-free season

Get more out of your time with family and loved ones over the holidays by following these tips for a stress-free season.

2 computer techs in a computer shop holding up a computer server with the "hang loose" sign...

PC Laptops

A comprehensive guide to choosing the right computer

With these tips, choosing the right computer that fits your needs and your budget will be easier than ever.

crowds of people in a German style Christmas market...

This Is The Place Heritage Park

Celebrate Christkindlmarket at This Is The Place Heritage Park!

The Christkindlmarket is an annual holiday celebration influenced by German traditions and generous giving.

Image of pretty woman walking in snowy mountains. Portrait of female wearing warm winter earmuff, r...

Lighting Design

Brighten your mood this winter with these lighting tricks

Read our lighting tips on how to brighten your mood in the winter if you are experiencing seasonal affective disorder.

A kitchen with a washer and dryer and a refrigerator...

Appliance Man

Appliance Man: a trusted name in Utah’s home appliance industry

Despite many recent closures of local appliance stores, Appliance Man remains Utah's trusted home appliance business and is here to stay.

abstract vector digital social network technology background...

Les Olson

Protecting yourself against social engineering attacks

Learn more about the common types of social engineering to protect your online or offline assets from an attack.

Ryan Smith teases reimagined downtown SLC with new arena as lawmakers debate billions in subsidies