POLITICS & ELECTIONS

US Supreme Court declines to hear Phil Lyman’s challenge of Utah primary system

Jan 13, 2025, 1:30 PM | Updated: 1:42 pm

Utah Rep. Phil Lyman speaks during Utah’s gubernatorial GOP primary debate held at the Eccles Bro...

Utah Rep. Phil Lyman speaks during Utah’s gubernatorial GOP primary debate held at the Eccles Broadcast Center in Salt Lake City on Tuesday, June 11, 2024. (Isaac Hale, Deseret News)

(Isaac Hale, Deseret News)

SALT LAKE CITY — The United States Supreme Court announced Monday it had declined to hear the case of unsuccessful Republican gubernatorial candidate Phil Lyman that challenged the process used by Utah Gov. Spencer Cox to appear on the general election ballot.

The announcement came quietly, with Lyman’s legal motion appearing on the list of cases that were turned down by the nation’s final court of appeal over the weekend, marking the end of Lyman’s months-long battle to reverse the results of his primary defeat to Cox.

Cox was ceremonially inaugurated as governor for a second four-year term on Wednesday. Following the event, Cox told reporters he had not given Lyman’s Supreme Court appeal “a second thought.”

“That’s not a thing,” Cox said.

Despite Lyman’s legal setbacks, he has said he is committed to pursue future court challenges and to run for additional positions of influence within the Utah Republican Party.

Who is Phil Lyman?

Lyman, a former state lawmaker from Blanding, has centered his social-media-heavy campaign for governor around his disagreements with the state’s electoral system, alleging that the faults he sees in the process indicate the presence of fraud.

Lyman beat Cox at the state party convention in April, securing 67.5% support among the nearly 4,000 GOP delegates present, making Cox the first incumbent to not meet the convention’s 40% threshold to qualify for the primary ballot since a signature-gathering path was established a decade ago.

Cox had qualified for the primary ballot months earlier after submitting 28,000 voter signatures to the Lieutenant Governor’s Office, which oversees Utah elections. The primary nomination packets containing the signatures were verified by the Davis County Clerk’s Office.

A legislative audit report in October found that the Davis County Clerk’s Office had incorrectly validated a small number of Cox’s signatures with an error rate of 2.4%, similar to that of other signature-gathering candidates. This signature verification error rate may have meant that Cox qualified for the primary without initially reaching the threshold for valid voter signatures.

However, the audit stressed that the small error rate in the signature verification process did not have any effect on the validity of Cox’s primary qualification or Cox’s primary victory because Cox followed the law each step of the way and could have easily submitted extra signatures.

Cox defeated Lyman to win the Utah Republican Party’s nomination in the June GOP primary election with 54% of the vote to Lyman’s 45% among nearly 427,000 Utah Republican voters.

Immediately after the election was called for Cox, Lyman told reporters he was exploring a constitutional challenge to SB54, the 10-year-old law that allows candidates to qualify for the primary election ballot either at the party’s convention or by gathering signatures.

Lyman’s Utah argument

On Aug. 1, one week after losing to Cox in the primary by more than 37,500 votes, Lyman filed a lawsuit with the Utah Supreme Court against Cox; Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson, the state’s chief election officer; Utah GOP chair Rob Axson; and the Utah Republican Party.

Lyman asked the court to “set aside and annul” the results of the 2024 primary election for himself and other candidates who received more than 60% at the Utah GOP nominating convention.

Lyman argued that SB54 did not change internal party bylaws which say that if a candidate exceeds 60% at convention they advance straight to the general election without a “direct” primary election.

Lyman asked the state’s highest court to certify his own placement on the general election ballot as the Republican Party’s nominee for governor with an additional order to immediately remove Cox from office for “malfeasance.”

But in August, the Utah Supreme Court ruled that Lyman’s petition for judicial action failed to show “a legal basis for setting aside the 2024 Republican primary election.”

Lyman’s request to throw out the 2024 primary and place himself on the general election ballot was based on the view that the “Republican Party’s internal procedures trump state election law,” the court said. “We disagree.”

“The party must comply with state law, including the requirement that members be allowed to seek the party’s nomination for elective office through signature gathering and/or convention process,” the court decision read. “Mr. Lyman cites no authority to support his assertion that a political party’s internal rules override state election law.”

The court had rejected a similar argument several years ago when the Utah GOP sued the state over SB54.

Lyman’s Supreme Court case

In October, Lyman appealed his argument to the U.S. Supreme Court, filing his request pro se, or without any legal representation, as he had done in his Utah Supreme Court case.

Lyman asked the Supreme Court’s nine justices to “review the judgment of the Utah Supreme Court, the court of last resort, and remand the case back for further proceedings.”

Lyman argued that the state’s primary election law, which was upheld by The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in 2018, is unconstitutional because it violates “freedom of association under the First Amendment,” leading to a “deprivation of rights protected by the United States Constitution.”

Throughout the repetitive 32-page argument, Lyman expressed frustration that Utah’s election system gives candidates who lose at convention a “second chance” at winning their party’s nomination during a primary, forcing him as the convention winner “to face an additional challenge.”

Lyman filed an additional motion with the Supreme Court on Nov. 21, requesting an emergency injunction to halt the Nov. 25 certification of Cox’s victory in the general election. This request was denied by Justice Neil Gorsuch on Dec. 13.

Lyman had participated in the election as a write-in candidate where he received 13.6% of the vote to Cox’s 52.9%.

Lyman not finished

On Dec. 11, an amicus brief supporting Lyman’s arguments was submitted on behalf of Riverton Mayor Trent Staggs, who had received nearly 70% at the state convention in the race for U.S. Senate, before losing by 16% to Sen. John Curtis in the primary.

Staggs, along with State Board of Education candidate Kris Kimball, 71 state delegates, 36 county delegates, and another 238 Utah voters, argued that Lyman’s lawsuit stood apart from previous litigation over SB54 because Lyman, Staggs and others had standing as candidates who were directly harmed by the law.

“Abandoning the ability of a party to nominate its chosen candidate and to communicate its nomination to general election voters cuts to the heart of the political association rights of a political party,” the brief said.

In October, conservative election law expert Audrey Perry said she would be “baffled” if the U.S. Supreme Court chose to pick up Lymna’s case because the court almost never chooses to interfere with elections, particularly when the question has already been decided by a state supreme court.

During a video livestream on Thursday, Lyman and his former running mate, Natalie Clawson, told their supporters that the Supreme Court could order a special election for governor in Utah and asked for donations to help fund their legal efforts and political futures.

“We care genuinely about these issues and we’re not going away,” Lyman said. “Whether we shift into trying to effect the GOP itself with leadership or running in four years. … We’re not quitting.”

KSL 5 TV Live

Politics & Elections

President Donald Trump speaks to reporters aboard Air Force One where Trump signed a proclamation d...

Zeke Miller and Sam Magdy, Associated Press

Trump says no right of return for Palestinians in Gaza under his plan for US ‘ownership’

President Donald Trump says Palestinians in Gaza would not have a right to return under his plan for U.S. “ownership” of the war-torn territory.

4 hours ago

In this photo illustration, pennies are seen on a table on February 10, 2025 in New York City. U.S....

Jill Colvin, Associated Press

Trump says he has directed US Treasury to stop minting new pennies, citing rising cost

President Donald Trump says he has directed the Treasury Department to stop minting new pennies, citing the rising cost of producing the one-cent coin.

5 hours ago

The Utah State Capitol is pictured in Salt Lake City on Thursday, Jan. 2, 2025....

Allessandra Harris Gurr, KSL NewsRadio

Privilege tax may be added to the Point of the Mountain

A proposed bill may bring a privilege tax to the Point of the Mountain development.

6 hours ago

U.S. President Donald Trump, left, and Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau talk prior to a NATO ...

Jim Morris, Associated Press

Justin Trudeau reportedly says Trump’s talk of making Canada a US state is ‘a real thing’

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says President Donald Trump’s talk of making Canada the 51st state is “a real thing” and is linked to the country’s rich natural resources.

3 days ago

Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump, left, claps as Tesla and SpaceX CEO ...

Anthony Izaguirre associated press

19 states sue to stop DOGE from accessing Americans’ personal data

Nineteen Democratic attorneys general have sued President Donald Trump to stop Elon Musk’s DOGE from accessing Treasury Department records.

3 days ago

FILE: On the same day the Utah’s Senate unanimously passed a resolution to bring an NHL franchise...

Daniella Rivera

‘You are inviting rapists to Utah’: Survivor urges lawmakers to consider consent bill

Year after year, Utah lawmakers have resisted or ignored efforts to close what experts and advocates say is a gap in the state’s sexual assault laws. The lawmaker behind those efforts hopes this year will be different.

3 days ago

Sponsored Articles

luxury living room with a classic white sofa and sofa, interior design...

Lighting Design

Revisiting home lighting trends for 2025

Looking for inspiration to revamp your home lighting? This article outlines some of the emerging lighting trends for 2025.

holiday gift basket with blue tissue paper and gingerbread cookies...

Kneaders Bakery & Cafe

Holiday hacks for a stress-free season

Get more out of your time with family and loved ones over the holidays by following these tips for a stress-free season.

2 computer techs in a computer shop holding up a computer server with the "hang loose" sign...

PC Laptops

A comprehensive guide to choosing the right computer

With these tips, choosing the right computer that fits your needs and your budget will be easier than ever.

crowds of people in a German style Christmas market...

This Is The Place Heritage Park

Celebrate Christkindlmarket at This Is The Place Heritage Park!

The Christkindlmarket is an annual holiday celebration influenced by German traditions and generous giving.

Image of pretty woman walking in snowy mountains. Portrait of female wearing warm winter earmuff, r...

Lighting Design

Brighten your mood this winter with these lighting tricks

Read our lighting tips on how to brighten your mood in the winter if you are experiencing seasonal affective disorder.

A kitchen with a washer and dryer and a refrigerator...

Appliance Man

Appliance Man: a trusted name in Utah’s home appliance industry

Despite many recent closures of local appliance stores, Appliance Man remains Utah's trusted home appliance business and is here to stay.

US Supreme Court declines to hear Phil Lyman’s challenge of Utah primary system