COLD PODCAST

Joyce Yost’s Rape Case First Prosecuted Without Victim To Testify

Apr 20, 2021, 10:27 PM | Updated: Apr 21, 2021, 12:16 am

FARMINGTON, Utah — In a case of he-said-she-said, who is a judge or jury to believe when “she” isn’t actually there to say anything?

The disappearance of Joyce Yost 10 days before she was scheduled to testify in a felony kidnapping and sexual assault trial left prosecutors in an unusual position. They faced the task of trying the case without a victim in court acting as the accuser and key witness.

“It was the first time we prosecuted a rape case without a victim in the state of Utah,” former Clearfield police detective William Holthaus said. “We were pretty nervous.”

The unconventional case is a pivotal point in the second season of KSL’s investigative podcast series COLD, which focuses on Yost’s disappearance.

Background of the Case

Holthaus had interviewed Yost on the morning of April 4, 1985, just a couple hours after she’d first reported being kidnapped and raped by a man she did not know. Holthaus then identified Douglas Anderson Lovell as a suspect and arrested him later that same day.

Yost went on to testify at a preliminary hearing two months later, not realizing Lovell was then secretly plotting to have her killed. Her testimony resulted in Utah 2nd District Court Judge Rodney Page advancing the case to arraignment and scheduling a trial for August 20, 1985.

Yost disappeared on the night of August 10, 1985 and efforts to locate her in time for the trial failed. Investigators at the time suspected foul play and believed Lovell was responsible, but were unable to prove it.

“At the time I didn’t think he was, frankly, dumb enough to do it himself,” Holthaus said in a May, 2020 interview for COLD.

Strength of the Evidence

The very nature of rape and sexual assault cases — which often involve just a single suspect and victim and no outside witnesses — mean prosecutors most often build their cases around the testimony of the victim.

There were no direct witnesses to Yost’s sexual assault, though she had told her sister what’d happened immediately afterward. Holthaus had also observed evidence which supported Yost’s account, including her own physical injuries.

“I believed what she was saying based on the evidence that I first saw,” Holthaus said.

Utah 2nd District Court issued a subpoena commanding Joyce Yost to appear for the kidnapping and sexual assault trial against Douglas Lovell. Yost had disappeared months earlier and did not respond to the subpoena.

Without Yost there to testify herself, prosecutors requested a delay in the trial. Deputy Davis County Attorney Brian Namba, the lead prosecutor on the case, had to consider whether he could secure a conviction if Yost didn’t return.

Namba pressed forward with the case and the court rescheduled the trial for Dec. 11, 1985. The court also issued a subpoena to Yost, which went unanswered. Lovell’s defense attorney insisted that the circumstances surrounding her disappearance not be disclosed to the jurors. Namba and the judge agreed they would only be told she was unavailable to testify for reasons unrelated to the case.

“Which turns out not to be true,” Namba said, “but that was our stipulation in order to allow the jury to deliberate fairly on the rape issue.”

Testimony by Proxy

At the trial, Lovell testified that Yost had willingly consented to have sex with him. This was contrary to what Yost had said both in interviews with police as well as at the preliminary hearing.

To counter this, Namba employed a tactic that was relatively untested at the time. He introduced Yost’s testimony from the preliminary hearing as evidence, having an attorney’s office secretary named Marily Gren read the transcript in Yost’s place.

“The danger of doing that kind of a case is that [the jurors] blow off the testimony thinking ‘well, she didn’t even think enough of it to come here herself,’” Namba said.

Former Davis County Attorney’s Office secretary Marily Gren holds a transcript of Joyce Yost’s preliminary hearing testimony during an interview for COLD on June 12, 2020. (Photo: Dave Cawley, KSL Podcasts)

Lovell’s defense attorney objected on the grounds it was hearsay and deprived Lovell of his constitutional right to confront his accuser. Judge Rodney Page overruled the objection, noting Yost’s prior testimony had been subjected to cross-examination during the preliminary hearing and as such was exempted from a rule barring the admission of hearsay testimony.

The jury convicted Lovell, largely on the strength of Yost’s prior testimony and Gren’s presentation of it.

“You have to engage the jury so that they feel [Yost’s] presence,” Namba said. “I think [Gren] really accomplished that.

KSL 5 TV Live

COLD Podcast

FILE - Douglass Lovell in a Utah Courtroom....

Larry D. Curtis

Utah Supreme Court overturns death sentence, upholds conviction for murder of Joyce Yost

The Utah Supreme Court overturned the death sentence of a man convicted of sexual assault, kidnapping, and murder over the discussion of his religion at his sentencing hearing.

2 months ago

Cary Hartmann being escorted by authorities in 1987....

Dave Cawley, KSL Podcasts

Suspect in Utah cold case back in prison on unrelated parole violation

A registered sex offender who spent more than 30 years in prison for sexually assaulting multiple women in Ogden during the 1980s is back in custody, after four years on parole.

5 months ago

FILE - Douglass Lovell in a Utah Courtroom....

Dave Cawley, KSL Podcasts

Supreme Court questions ‘injection’ of religion into death penalty trial of Douglas Lovell

Douglas Lovell has submitted an appeal to the Utah Supreme Court over issues related to religious discussion during his trial for the murder of Joyce Yost.

8 months ago

law enforcement gathered around a possible mountain gravesite in brush on a mountain top...

Dan Rascon, Andrew Adams, and Mary Culbertson, KSL TV

No human remains found in possible burial site in 1985 cold case

Wednesday was a day of optimism and hope in a nearly 40-year-old murder mystery case of a woman from Roy, Utah.

1 year ago

law enforcement gathered around a possible mountain gravesite in brush on a mountain top...

Dave Cawley, KSL TV

Police to investigate possible mountain gravesite in 1985 cold case

Police confirmed to KSL5 they plan to excavate a possible gravesite in the mountains near Causey Reservoir on Wednesday in connection with a 1985 cold case.

1 year ago

News paper clippings of  Nancy Perry Baird's murder. (KSLTV)...

Dave Cawley and Keira Fairmont

Blamed on Bundy: COLD podcast challenges popular theory in Nancy Baird cold case

The unsolved 1975 disappearance of Nancy Baird from East Layton, Utah has long been attributed to serial killer Ted Bundy. KSL’S COLD podcast gained exclusive access to case files that point toward other more probable suspects.

1 year ago

Sponsored Articles

abstract vector digital social network technology background...

Les Olson

Protecting yourself against social engineering attacks

Learn more about the common types of social engineering to protect your online or offline assets from an attack.

family having fun at home...

Lighting Design

Discover the impact of lighting on your mood

From color temperature to lighting saturation, we tackle how different lighting design setups can impact your day-to-day mood.

Laptops in a modern technology store. Department of computers in the electronics store. Choosing a ...

PC Laptops

How to choose the best laptop for college students

Finding the right laptop for college students can be hard, but with this guide we break down what to look for so you can find the best one.

young male technician is repairing a printer at office...

Les Olson

Unraveling the dilemma between leasing and buying office technology

Carefully weigh these pros and cons to make an informed decision that best suits your business growth and day-to-day operation. 

A kitchen in a modern farmhouse....

Lighting Design

A room-by-room lighting guide for your home

Bookmark this room-by-room lighting guide whenever you decide to upgrade your lighting or style a new home.

Photo courtesy of Artists of Ballet West...

Ballet West

The rising demand for ballet tickets: why they’re harder to get

Ballet West’s box office is experiencing demand they’ve never seen before, leaving many interested patrons unable to secure tickets they want.

Joyce Yost’s Rape Case First Prosecuted Without Victim To Testify