KSL INVESTIGATES

After a water main break, who pays for damage – the city or its residents?

Nov 19, 2021, 6:35 AM

PARK CITY, Utah – When a city water main breaks and sends water flooding into homes and businesses, someone must take care of the mess. But who is responsible for paying for the damage: the city, or its residents?

Park City resident Mark Stemler believes the city should be responsible for the damage to his home. But court filings show the city denies negligence, pointing to the Governmental Immunity Act.

A River Runs Through It

“The water raced down through the floorboards into the crawlspace,” said Stemler as he described to the KSL Investigators the damage done to his century-plus-old home near Main Street in downtown Park City.

A water main burst on the night of July 11, 2019, creating a huge sinkhole right next to Stemler’s home. It also sent thousands and thousands of gallons of water into the house, soaking carpet and furniture in the basement and ruining much of the drywall. The flood left a watermark nearly a foot above the floor.

As bad as that damage was, the foundation got it much worse.

A structural engineer found the water pooled up to two feet high. It saturated the soil that provided support to footings, enough to reduce the soil’s density. All that movement destabilized the foundation, including two piers of stacked concrete blocks, according to the engineer’s report.

So how much will all that damage cost to repair?

“Well, I’m thinking a few hundred-thousand dollars,” said Stemler.

Who is Responsible?

Stemler said his home insurance will cover the drywall, but the policy will not touch the foundation. He believes Park City should be responsible for that. After all, it was their water main that broke. He said in the 29 months since the break, he still has not received one dime from the city.

In most situations, a city’s liability for damages caused by a broken water main stop at the meter between the main and the home’s supply line. From that point on, it is up to the homeowner to take care of damages. But Stemler’s situation isn’t like most.

On the day after the break, Park City municipal officials told KSL TV the cause could be related to new pavement. Hours before the water main burst, a road crew contracted by the city put down fresh asphalt above the pipeline, right next to Stemler’s house.

“The gentleman from the city said the rupture was most likely created by the compaction and the work that had been done with the asphalt that day,” Stemler said.

On the night of the water main break, a viewer sent KSL this video of the torrent of water running on Park City’s Main Street.

Making matters worse, that crew covered lids in the street that would have given responders access to the main’s valves. And the access lids were covered without their location being marked. On the night of the break, public works and fire crews had dig through that new asphalt to find those valves.

“They spent over three hours trying to locate them so they could get them open, so they could turn them off,” Stemler explained.

Governmental Immunity & Negligence

Stemler has filed suit against Park City and its asphalt paving contractor, alleging that the covering up of the valve access covers, among many other things, amounts to gross negligence. But does his argument — hold water?

Attorney Robert Sykes does not represent Stemler or Park City or its asphalt paving contractor, but he researches and practices government claims law and believes Stemler may have a case.

Attorney Robert Sykes explains to KSL’s Matt Gephardt how a city could still be held liable for a water main break under the Governmental Immunity Act of Utah. (KSL TV)

Sykes said in general, under the Governmental Immunity Act of Utah, municipalities cannot be held liable for acts constituting a government function, such as delivering water to homes or businesses, unless negligence can be proven. Under its Waivers of Immunity provision, a government entity can be liable if its work creates a defective, unsafe or dangerous condition of any highway, road, culvert, bridge, tunnel, alley, crosswalk, viaduct or structure located on them or other public improvement.

“It seems to me that you’ve got the defective, dangerous condition of a highway or a road,” said Sykes. “And the reason you have that is because they cover it up and didn’t get in there fast enough so they could fix something.”

Park City officials also told media that the cause was a broken valve. And there was another complication: A city spokeswoman told KSL the day after the break that the “valves were somewhat rusted and that was contributing to the incident.”

“I would argue that a rusted valve is negligence,” Sykes said. “Because that’s very predictable that you turn a rusty valve, and it breaks.”

Through KSL and other media outlets, the city also asked residents and businesses to contact the city to report property damage.

“They’re making an admission against interest,” Sykes explained. “That’s admissible in court.”

So, what does Park City have to say about all this now? In an emailed statement to the KSL Investigators, not much. “As is standard with matters of pending litigation, Park City Municipal has no comment on this case.”

However, in court filings, the city’s attorneys deny Stemler’s allegations of negligence, saying there is no proof. And they invoke Utah’s Governmental Immunity Act.

The Growing Risk of Water Main Breaks

But issues caused by water main breaks will not end in a Park City courtroom, or in Stemler’s crawlspace.

A 2018 survey of over 300 utilities in the U.S. and Canada by Utah State University researchers found water main breaks surged 27% overall between 2012 and 2018. Breaks in old water mains built out of cast iron or cement asbestos increased by over 40%. Pipes made of those two materials alone make up 41% of all water mains in North America according to the report. And at that time, only 58% of those utilities said they had a regular pipe replacement program. Most of those old water mains have only gotten older since.

It’s not very hard to find examples.

This past July, a water main break impacted 15 homes in Murray. Another break created a geyser that shut down a freeway offramp near downtown Salt Lake City in September. That same day, another broken Park City water main sent mud and water onto Snow Creek Plaza’s parking lot. And in October, St. George News reported the rupture of a 50-year-old main in St. George’s Bloomington Hills area that sent water into a home’s basement.

Don’t Bank on Insurance

If proving a city is negligent is an uphill battle, how can homeowners protect themselves? Well, don’t count on your homeowner’s policy, explained insurance expert Les Masterson of Insure.com.

“It’s just not a covered peril. It’s not like a fire or vandalism — those types of things that are usually covered,” Masterson said. “The insurers think that’s not their responsibility. That’s the city or town’s responsibility to make sure that doesn’t happen.”

Masterson says most flood insurance policies will not cover water main breaks. They’re for covering damage caused by weather. However, an add-on policy for a homeowner might be available.

“If it’s something that concerns someone, they should definitely ask about it and see if it’s possible to be added to the policy, understanding that it will cost more money,” said Masterson.

As for Stemler and his damaged home, he vows to keep fighting Park City’s city hall.

Mark Stemler explains to KSL’s Matt Gephardt why he believes the city is liable for the damage to his home.

“If you damage your neighbor’s property, you don’t look for legal angles to try to avoid paying for it,” he said. “You go in and make it right.”

Pipe Replacement Program

The KSL Investigators asked Park City Municipal if it does have some sort of pipe replacement program in place. In a statement they told us:

“Park City Public Utilities’ asset management program includes an inventory of all significant assets, including underground infrastructure — this involves monitoring age, size, type, condition, and performance. We use this information to establish our replacement priorities. Our goal is to minimize water service interruption to our customers and minimize potential damage associated with water pipe failures.”

KSL Investigates

A silhouetted man sitting in a chair on a phone call....

Matt Gephardt and Sloan Schrage, KSL TV

New federal data shows favorite methods of scammers targeting Utahns

Over 26,200 Utahns reported getting hit by fraud to the Federal Trade Commission last year. And one out of five of those Utahns lost money to imposters.

3 days ago

According to new data from Carfax, at the end of last year, there were 609,000 vehicles with an unf...

Matt Gephardt

600,000 cars in Utah need recalls fixed, what is holding up the repair work?

According to new data from Carfax, at the end of last year, there were 609,000 vehicles with an unfixed recall in Utah.

5 days ago

Lynzee Delapaz explains to KSL’s Matt Gephardt how her car was damaged when it collided with anot...

Matt Gephardt and Sloan Schrage

Get Gephardt: Who’s legally responsible for damage when cars collide in a car wash?

A Grantsville woman’s car was damaged inside a car wash when the vehicle ahead of her went off the tracks. So, who pays for the damage?

6 days ago

Matt Gephardt speaking to Thelissa Mead about Hyundai not responding to her claims and getting her ...

Matt Gephardt

Get Gephardt helps Utah Hyundai owner seeking reimbursement for overestimated fuel economy

A major automaker was accused of saying their cars get better mileage than they really do, And they promised to pay their customers back. But when one Utah customer wasn't, she decided to Get Gephardt.

10 days ago

Candidates for the Republican primary's Utah’s 3rd Congressional District in a televised debate a...

Daniella Rivera and Annie Knox

KSL Truth Test: Fact-checking GOP candidates in race for Utah’s open US House seat

The KSL Investigators looked into claims from five Republican candidates vying to replace Rep. John Curtis in the U.S. House of Representatives.

11 days ago

...

Daniella Rivera and Annie Knox

KSL Truth Test: Fact-checking claims from GOP candidates for Utah governor

The KSL Investigators fact-check a range of statements from Utah's GOP gubernatorial candidates.

12 days ago

Sponsored Articles

Photo courtesy of Artists of Ballet West...

Ballet West

The rising demand for ballet tickets: why they’re harder to get

Ballet West’s box office is experiencing demand they’ve never seen before, leaving many interested patrons unable to secure tickets they want.

Electrician repairing ceiling fan with lamps indoors...

Lighting Design

Stay cool this summer with ceiling fans

When used correctly, ceiling fans help circulate cool and warm air. They can also help you save on utilities.

Side view at diverse group of children sitting in row at school classroom and using laptops...

PC Laptops

5 internet safety tips for kids

Read these tips about internet safety for kids so that your children can use this tool for learning and discovery in positive ways.

Women hold card for scanning key card to access Photocopier Security system concept...

Les Olson

Why printer security should be top of mind for your business

Connected printers have vulnerable endpoints that are an easy target for cyber thieves. Protect your business with these tips.

Modern chandelier hanging from a white slanted ceiling with windows in the backgruond...

Lighting Design

Light up your home with these top lighting trends for 2024

Check out the latest lighting design trends for 2024 and tips on how you can incorporate them into your home.

Technician woman fixing hardware of desktop computer. Close up....

PC Laptops

Tips for hassle-free computer repairs

Experiencing a glitch in your computer can be frustrating, but with these tips you can have your computer repaired without the stress.

After a water main break, who pays for damage – the city or its residents?